Tag Archives: 2022 vancouver civic election

#VanElxn 2022 | Five Candidates Vie to Become Vancouver Mayor | Part 1

In 2022, there are a record five serious-minded candidates intent on occupying the Mayor’s office following the October 15th Vancouver municipal election.

One of these stalwart persons of character and intent who would lead is …

Edward Charles Kennedy Stewart (born November 8, 1966), who has sat as Vancouver’s Mayor since being elected to office in a close fought race in 2018.

Recently, Mayoral candidate rival and current sitting Vancouver City Councillor Colleen Hardwick, was asked to say something nice about Mr. Stewart, for an article to be published later this month. Ms. Hardwick’s response, “He once played bass in a band.”  Which, if you come right down to it, pretty much encapsulates Mayor Stewart’s contribution to the life and politics of his adopted (he was born in Halifax) home town of Vancouver, over the course of the past, almost, four years.

In recent days, VanRamblings has referred to Mr. Stewart as hapless. But a more accurate description of his time as Mayor would be the following word …

Indeed, for much of the past four years, Mr. Stewart has proved an in absentia Mayor, rarely if ever around, absent from the public eye for much of the pandemic — except when he was whining to the press about how “Vancouver needs more money, the federal and provincial governments have to help us” … with, all the while, OneCity Councillor Christine Boyle and Green Councillor, Adriane Carr having gone rogue, demanding a 15% property tax increase, because “the pandemic presents us with a golden opportunity to address our climate emergency” … with nary a contrary word of disagreement heard from Mr. Stewart.

Where other Canadian mayors —  think Don Iveson in Edmonton, Naheed Nenshi in Calgary, John Tory in Toronto — pulled their respective Councils together to forward the cause of the citizens they’d been elected to represent, Mayors who not only acted like but were true, red-blooded statesmen in a time of crisis, Vancouver Mayor Kennedy Stewart — lacking any evident leadership skills or abilties — allowed a fractious Vancouver City Council to go hither, thither and yon pursuing their own political agendas, far too often at the expense of the public interest.

Stewart: unavailable to the press — a lesson he seems to have learned from former Conservative Prime Minister, Stephen Harper —  given over to near hourly meetings with various well-heeled developers (who would fund his re-election campaign), these greed merchants brought to the Mayor’s suite by former Vision Councillor Raymond Louie, who since the last Vancouver civic election has acted as an extremely well-paid lobbyist for Vancouver’s development industry.

The icing on the cake for Mr. Stewart’s tenuous (and we hope soon to end) era in the Mayor’s chair is the bastardized Burnaby by-law proposal wherein he’s promised the construction of affordable housing amidst the burgeoning greenhouse gas-emitting concrete-and-steel massive tower developments that will envelop the “Broadway Corridor” from Clark to Vine, from the Inlet to 16th Avenue …

In May 2019, Burnaby City Council adopted a ‘best in Canada’ tenant assistance policy that provides support for tenants displaced from rental buildings with 5-plus apartments, mandating developers cover tenants’ moving costs (up to $1,400), and pay the difference between a tenant’s current rent and the rent in the new building tenants move to while construction is underway, providing the …

Right of first refusal to displaced tenants to move into the replacement building once construction is complete, at the same rent as they paid before being displaced (subject only to the provincially mandated maximum annual increases), as well as mandating that developers will again have to cover moving costs when tenants move back into the new building.

Mr. Stewart’s affordable housing plan does not encompass the notion that developers would pay the difference between a tenant’s current rent and the rent in the new building tenants move to — where would tenants move to in their neighbourhood or in Vancouver, who’d been paying $1100 a month for their rent, where would they find such accommodation at a similar monthly rate … Spuzzum?

The other “flaw” in Mr. Stewart’s so-called “plan” is that tenants who would be displaced from their livable four or five storey buildings, where one-bedroom suites encompassed 700+ square feet, would upon completion of the new building return five years later to the  40-story purpose-built rental building where one-bedroom suites would encompass only a postage-stamp sized 395 square foot apartment.

Kennedy Stewart: the worst Vancouver Mayor since Jack Volrich’s greasily reductive, inauspicious, and best forgotten, late 1970s two-year term in office.

Last week, Mayor Kennedy Stewart held a press conference, to address the issue of the tent city along East Hastings, between Carrall Street and Main. There was in his demeanour a sense of frustration and melancholy, verging on defeat. For the first time in his 33-month tenure as Mayor, there was about him a humanity that, prior to that press conference, had not been previously witnessed by this reporter.

Here’s what Vancouver Mayor Kennedy Stewart had to say …

“For more than 3 years, my administration has worked in concert with all of our elected Councillors, city staff, the provincial and federal governments, as well as a myriad of social agencies to find a resolution to our ongoing homelessness problem.

As Mayor, I’ve been down to Hastings Street and spoken with some of those who are  resident in the tents that we see strewn along East Hastings. I’ve spoken with homeless advocates Fiona York and Sarah Blyth, asked them what my administration can do to alleviate the human misery we are witness to each and every day.

The answer is always the same: housing that will provide dignity. A home with a bedroom, a fully stocked kitchen, a living room with a sofa, a dining room, comfortable furniture, the amenities of life.

Having spoken with various senior administrators at B.C. Housing, I’ve been told that housing is on its way, but not until this autumn.

What to do now, though, in the midst of this housing crisis?

I am at my wit’s end as to how we, collectively as a society, how my administration, and the provincial and federal governments will resolve, once and for all, Vancouver’s homelessness crisis. I want to assure you that I, personally, my administration, our Vancouver City Councillors, city staff, and senior levels of government are working together to find resolution to the issue of the human misery to which we are witness each and every day.”

For the first time since he took office early in November 2018, Mayor Kennedy admitted that there was a homelessness crisis that he had previously not acknowledged, in as full and forthright and humane a manner as he did at his press conference last week. There was no whining, no “it’s not my fault, the federal government is not giving me the money I need”, no meaningless “woke” nostrums about how those who express a concern about tent cities are doing nothing more than engaging on an unwholesome and mean-spirited attack on the poor.

What there was, though: a display of humanity, how we’re all in this together, how resolving the issue of homelessness is a struggle we should all be engaged in.

A few more displays of humanity before the October 15th election, a fidelity in his speech, in his words and intent and, hell, Kennedy Stewart may well be re-elected to a second term of office, with realigned priorities and a new sense of purpose.

#VanElxn2022 | 10 Political Parties Running for Office in Vancouver in 2022

Two months from today, late in the evening of Saturday, October 15th, Vancouver voters will have elected a new civic government to a term in office, extending through until 2026, in the most critically important civic election in fifty years.

In the 2018 Vancouver municipal election — which saw Vision Vancouver swept from office after 10 years in power at Vancouver City Hall — voters were asked to choose between seventy-one candidates vying for ten City Council seats, a record number of candidates in a  Vancouver civic election, and reportedly the largest — and certainly most confusing — voting ballot ever compiled in any Canadian city.

Come October, when advance polls open, the civic ballot may well be even larger.

Today on VanRamblings, in the first of 30 or so columns we’ll publish leading up to the October 15th municipal election, we’ll provide a brief introduction to the 10 political parties which have registered candidates for office in Vancouver in 2022.

Note: Mayor Kennedy Stewart and all 10 City Councillors are seeking re-election.

The deadline for nominations is September 9, so more candidates could be added.

Over the course of the next two weeks, VanRamblings will provide in-depth insight into each of the political parties, their policies, and what the selection of the candidates for each party would portend for the post October 15th four year period.

VanRamblings columns will be informational, but also — as per usual in our writing —  pointed and snarkily opinionated to, we hope you’ll find, an entertaining degree. With a couple of exceptions, we’re not going to go after candidates — given that we have much respect for those who come forward to offer themselves up for public service — but will provide our usual idiosyncratic, dare we say caustic take on the 10 political parties serving up candidates for your appreciative delectation.

Suffice to say, what you’ll read on VanRamblings, you’ll find nowhere else.

VanRamblings will also provide insight into each of the five Mayoral candidates — yes, there are once again five Mayoral candidates seeking office in Vancouver’s 2022 civic election, with the NPA choosing Fred Harding as their new standard bearer, after longtime Park Board Commissioner John Coupar stepped down 9 days ago — and what their election to the Mayor’s chair would portend for the woebegotten, too often beleaguered and much put upon citizens of Vancouver.

The 10 Vancouver Civic Parties Offering Candidates in 2022

Forward Together (Mayor + 3 candidates): The name of the new party led by Mayor Kennedy Stewart, who is seeking re-election. Software engineer Russil Wvong; Harvard and MIT graduate Dulcy Anderson (someone whom we really like, having worked with her often in her capacity as Vancouver Point Grey MLA David Eby’s senior constituency assistant); and educator and accessibility advocate, Hilary Brown, are their Council candidates, with more potentially to be added.

ABC Vancouver (Mayor + 7 candidates): Sitting Vancouver City Councillors, elected in 2018 as NPA (Non Partisan Association) candidates, Vancouver East’s Rebecca Bligh, who sits on the Selection Committee at CIty Hall vetting candidates for the 33 advisory committees at City Hall; former School Board trustee and in her time working in the Ministry of Education in Victoria worked to create the SOGI programme, the inimitable Lisa Dominato; and long one of VanRamblings’ favourite electeds, the quite spectacular Sarah Kirby-Yung (you can thank her for the business-saving restaurant patios we all enjoy), are seeking re-election under the ABC banner in 2022, and are joined on the ballot by VanRamblings’ very good friend (and webmaster), Mike Klassen; former online news producer and reporter with Global B.C., Peter Meiszner; former VPD spokesperson, Brian Montague;Manager of Operations Engineering,  at B.C. Children’s Hospital, Lenny Zhou.

Ken Sim, who came in a close second in 2018, is ABC’s candidate for mayor.

Note should be made that VanRamblings will endorse ABC candidate Christopher Richardson — the finest man we know — for School Board. We’ll also be writing a feature piece, between now and election day, on the estimable Mr. Richardson.

TEAM for a Livable Vancouver (Mayor + 6 candidates): TEAM (The Electors’ Action Movement)  candidates for Vancouver City Council include former Vancouver Green Party Council candidate Cleta Brown, a former director of the Stephen Lewis Foundation, and a lawyer and investigator for British Columbia’s Ombudperson’s office; next, one of VanRamblings’ favourite candidates for a City Council seat in 2022, a director of the Fairview/South Granville Action Committee, recent Simon Fraser University MBA graduate, a bright, sharp as a pin advocate for neighbourhood community involvement in decision-making at Vancouver City Hall (in this neck of the woods we say: a social democrat), personable, possessed of humility (a political prerequisite for office, we believe), and as welcoming an individual as you’d ever want to meet, who would make — let’s face it — a great Vancouver City Councillor, the quite spectacular and must-elect Vancouver City Council candidate, the spectacularly talented Sean Nardi; in addition to Cleta and Sean, there’s a housing industry entrepreneur, par excellence, who has an abiding interest in green issues and fighting climate change, and will focus his campaign for office on housing affordability, business innovation, community wellness, and the underfunded and too often under supported arts community … Param Nijjar.

And let us not forget the no-nonsense Grace Quan, President and CEO at Hydrogen In Motion(H2M), and well … just read her LinkedIn profile to gain insight into why Ms. Quan is a must-elect for Vancouver City Council in 2022; Stephen P Roberts, who as Chief Operating Officer of a regional division in global investment banking managed multi-million dollar budgets and hundreds of staff, while heading up legal and compliance oversight, a longtime oenophile (i.e. a lover and connoisseur of wine), and ready to get to work post October 15th working on your behalf as a neighbourhood, community and dedicated environmental advocate; and last, but certainly not least, VanRamblings’ “next door neighbour” (he lives in the strata next door and to the west of VanRamblings’ housing co-op), longtime community advocate and just a general, all around fine human being, Bill Tieleman — another must, must, must elect to Vancouver City Council — the Director of Communications at the B.C. Federation of Labour in the 1980s, Director of Communications in the Glen Clark NDP government of the late 1990s, baseball fan (it’s a given that if you’re a social democrat, you must love baseball), and oenophile, as well, who has his own wine connoisseur website, WineBarbarian.ca

Sitting Vancouver City Councillor Colleen Hardwick is TEAM’s must, must elect candidate for Vancouver Mayor (about which we will go into detail another time).

Progress Vancouver (Mayor + 2 candidates): The name of one of the many (and fairly anonymous) new Vancouver civic partieswe’ll see if they register with voters in 2022this seeming passionate / vanity political project was created and is led by longtime federal Liberal political apparatchik, the handsome and gregarious, Mark Marissen who, after creating the YES Vancouver civic party in 2018 (Hector Bremner was their Mayoral candidate, the party barely registering at the polls that election year), decided to run for Mayor under the Progress Vancouver banner in 2022. So far, the party has announced two Council candidates, Mauro Francis, who defected from the NPA when John Coupar stepped down / was pushed out by the Board as the NPA’s Mayoral candidate, and standard bearer; and 2017 NDP candidate in Vancouver False Creek (who up until the last poll came in seemed certain to defeat former Vancouver Mayor, Sam Sullivan),  Morgane Oger, a human rights advocate, former Chair of the Vancouver District Parent Advisory Council, who sits on the City of Vancouver’s LGBTQ2+ Advisory Committee. VanRamblings likes, respects and admires Ms. Oger, who’ll definitely be on our recommended list come voting day.

Non-Partisan Association (Mayor + 5 candidates): The poor, poor NPA. Seemingly a lost cause in 2022, despite their 45 years in power at Vancouver City Hall, dating back to the party’s conception in 1937. Incumbent Vancouver City Councillor, Melissa De Genova is seeking re-election and in 2022 is joined on the ballot by Elaine Allan, Cinnamon Bhayani, Ken Charko, and Arezo Zarrabian, all of whom we kind of like, if truth be told. John Coupar was the NPA’s Mayoral candidate, but no more. Fred Harding, Vancouver First’s Mayoral candidate in 2018 (he barely registered on voting day), will be announced today as the NPA’s replacement Mayoral candidate.

The Vancouver Green Party candidates for Vancouver City Council, School Board and Park Board

Green Party (5 candidates): A couple of weeks back, incumbent Vancouver City Councillor Pete Fry (who we believe will be re-elected to Council in a walk) introduced us to new VanGreen City Council candidate, Stephanie Smith (no, not that one … she’s pictured on the left above), a longtime labour and social justice activist who lives in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside and is currently President of the Lore Krill Housing Co-op. We’re going to write a feature piece on Ms. Smith next month, but suffice to say for now that the entirely spectacular must-elect to Council Stephanie Smith is our favourite candidate for City Council in 2022.

Stephanie Smith is joined by incumbent City Councillors Adrianne Carr, Pete Fry (see above) and Michael Wiebe, as well as the outstanding Devyani Singh, all of whom we’ll be dedicating a grab bag column to at some point next month.

COPE (4 candidates): Incumbent Vancouver City Councillor Jean Swanson — who VanRamblings will be endorsing for Council come October — is seeking re-election. In 2022,  she is joined on the ballot by Breen Ouellette, Nancy Trigueros and Tanya Webking, all of whom we look forward to seeing on the campaign trail.

OneCity Vancouver (4 candidates):  One of the two Vancouver civic parties you must not vote for in 2022, run, run, run as fast as you can and far, far away from the Cult of Christine Boyle (she’s a current Vancouver City Councillor who you must not re-elect in 2022; we’ll explain why another time).  Joining Ms. Boyle on the ballot in 2022 are more must not elect newcomers to civic politics: the ever “woke” crew of  the reality-denying Iona Bonamis, Ian Cromwell and Matthew Norris.

OneCity Vancouver aka The Cult of Christine Boyle is not running a Mayoral candidate in 2022, but will support Vancouver Mayor Kennedy Stewart’s re-election.

Note, in passing: VanRamblings will enthusiastically support the re-election of Jennifer Reddy as a OneCity Board of Education trustee, and her outstanding colleague, Kyla Epstein, who we will champion (even if, as it appears, she doesn’t want us to … alas). We may endorse more OneCity School Board candidates.

Vision Vancouver (4 candidates): Hey, you thought they were dead? Naughty, naughty. Nope, Vision Vancouver is back with a vengeance in 2022, despite being unceremoniously ejected from civic office in 2018, this time out offering the Council candidacies of physician Honieh Barzegari (“hey, Canadian and B.C. governments: make it possible for Ms. Barzegari to continue in her profession as a family doctor, in Canada”); the don’t mess with her, longtime Vision Vancouver supporter, and outstanding communications specialist (and sort of impressive, we think) Lesli Boldt; current Park Board Chair and lifelong Green, Stuart Mackinnon (one of the two candidates running for office in 2022 you must not vote for under any circumstance); and Kits resident, parent of two teens, former CEO of the BC Non-Profit Housing Association and Chair of the BC Rental Housing Coalition, Kishone Roy. As is the case with OneCity Vancouver, a re-constituted Vision Vancouver is not running a Mayoral candidate in the current Vancouver municipal election, but instead will support the re-election of a hapless Mayor Stewart.

Note should be made that VanRamblings will enthusiastically support, and endorse, three Vision Vancouver School Board candidates: Aaron Leung, Steve Cardwell and Allan Wong, about whom we will write at some greater length during this civic election cycle.

Vote Socialist (1 candidate): New political party without a mayoral candidate.

Some days, there is no greater joy to be derived than reading Sean Orr’s long running column, Tea and Two Slices in Scout Magazine, founded by the late Andrew Morrison some two decades ago. Tea and Two Slices, and its author, Sean Orr, offer an anarchic but utterly humane (and often riotously funny) take on the issues of the day. In 2022, Sean has made a decision to transfer his words in print onto the political stage, as a truth teller ( an angry truth teller, but still …).

Unfortunately, and sad to say, Sean Orr is no Kshama Sawant, a Seattle City Councillor who ran for office in 2013 on a simple, achievable $15-an-hour minimum wage plan, ensuring a livable base wage rate for low paid workers. At the time, everyone thought she was mad, as she eked out a victory at the polls, defeating a longtime right-of-centre incumbent. In 2015, a $15-an-hour wage plan was passed by Seattle City Council, and implemented, Sawant’s “idea” proceeding to spread like wild fire across the United States, and across Canada. In 2022, a minimum wage of $15 and hour (or more; in B.C. , it’s $15.65, and due for a raise next June) was implemented in 2017, when the B.C. NDP formed government.

Sean Orr is Vote Socialist’s sole Council candidate for Vancouver City Council.

Although, Sean Orr’s prospects may not be good, the same cannot be said of Andrea Pinochet-Escudero, who VanRamblings will be endorsing as a Park Board Commissioner, to hold office over the next four years, should she win her bid for office, on October 15, 2022.

Note: In 2018, 26 Independents ran for office, while 16 candidates ran for Mayor.

star.jpg star.jpg star.jpg

If you’ve found any of what has been published today on VanRamblings confusing, the issues raised in this initial, comeback Vancouver civic affairs column and opinion piece will come into greater relief, and more orderly focus over the course of the next two months. We hope to see you here often over the next 62 days.

Tomorrow, VanRamblings will publish the first column in a four-part series introducing you to the five serious-minded Mayoral candidates seeking office in Vancouver, where — in order to help you keep your sanity — we’ll attempt to keep columns at under 1000 words (as requested by Straight editor, Charlie Smith).

Next week, VanRamblings will begin a series on why the current Vancouver civic election is the most crucial election held in our city since 1972, and how critically important it is you apprise yourself of the issues, and vote for the future you want.

#VanPoli | Taxes | Downloading the Tax Burden to Municipalities

In a disparaging VanRamblings story published last week on this site —  titled Vancouver City Council To Raise Property Taxes a Whopping 6.35% — we took Vancouver City Councillors to task for raising property taxes in our city beyond what most homeowners, small businesses, and landlords could reasonably afford.

Now, as it happens, VanRamblings is a big fan of taxes which, in good measure, pay for: our schools, from kindergarten through university post-graduate work; roads, highways, bridges and other transportation infrastructure (including public transit); our judicial and public safety systems (the courts, police, fire firefighters, paramedics, prisons); ‘social programmes’ including all aspects of child care (encompassing children in the care of the province, when family structures have broken down); all aspects of our vibrant health care system; and much, much more.

To be fair to Vancouver Mayor Kennedy Stewart, and the five Vancouver City Councillors who voted in favour of the 6.35% property tax increase in 2022 — that would be the three Green Party of Vancouver City Councillors, Pete Fry, Adriane Carr and Michael Wiebe, OneCity Vancouver’s Christine Boyle and COPE’s Jean Swanson —  as is our wont, today we’ll publish one of our infrequent “history lessons” to explain, at least in part, the rationale as to why the Mayor and five City Councillors cast their vote in favour of a  6.35% property tax increase for 2022.

In 1984, Conservative Party leader Brian Mulroney was elected as Canada’s 18th Prime Minister, supplanting a Liberal Party of Canada that had been in power for 21 consecutive years, Canada’s 33rd Parliament in the autumn of 1984 consisting of 202 Tories, 135 Liberals, and 31 New Democrats. During Mr. Mulroney’s nine years in power, his government had many successes, on the environment and on the trade front, negotiating a groundbreaking free trade agreement with the United States. Contrary to billing, more often than not, Conservatives in power tend to be spendthrifts, all while cutting taxes for corporations and the wealthy, and failing to keep an eye on the federal budget.

In the midst of a deepening recession, when Mr. Mulroney stepped down as Prime Minister of Canada on Friday June 25, 1993, apart from and in spite of the then wildly unpopular 7% Goods and Sales Tax (GST) his government had brought in, Mr. Mulroney left his successor, Kim Campbell, with the legacy of a multi-year $42 billion annual budget deficit — a grim sum absolutely unheard of in those days.

Only four short months later, on Monday, October 25th, 1993 Joseph Jacques Jean Chrétien was elected as Canada’s 20th Prime Minister. First order of business? Appoint a Finance Minister, and commit to not only eliminating the egregious annual deficit, but cut the accumulated $840 billion long term Mulroney legacy debt in half. Who would perform that masterful fiscal feat? The head of Canada Steamship Lines, from 1988 forward the Member of Parliament for the southwestern Montréal riding of LaSalle-Émard, and Prime Ministerial aspirant, Paul Martin.

In Canada, long ago the federal government negotiated what became known colloquially as a tax rental agreement with the provinces. The federal government would collect income taxes from Canadians, take a portion for federal coffers, while transferring the majority of the federal tax income collected back to the provinces. For years, back to 1945, the agreement worked well for all levels of government — until 1996, when Finance Minister Paul Martin “changed the game”.

In the 1995 federal budget Jean Chrétien’s Liberal government abandoned any pretense of federal financing of post-secondary education, changing what was known as the Canada Social Transfer into the renamed the Canada Health and Social Transfer(CHST), cutting a total of $3.5 billion in the CHST for the 1996/97 fiscal year. The total cuts to the provinces in the first five years Jean Chrétien was in power: $7.6 billion in transfer payments that would otherwise have gone to the provinces, or a devastating decline of 40.7% in health, education and other transfer payments to the provinces by the 1999-2000 federal fiscal year.

All of a sudden, the provinces were made almost entirely responsible for the largest provincial budget item: health care, and entirely responsible for funding post-secondary education, federally-funded programmes that had been in place since as far back as the end of World War II.

The good news for the federal government: by 2003 federal Liberal Finance Minister Paul Martin had not only eliminated any notion of an annual federal budget deficit — instead, creating a yearly surplus —  but had, as well, paid down $440 billion in long term debt, cutting the federal debt in half as Jean Chrétien had promised a decade earlier. The bad news for the provinces: provincial Premiers and their Finance Ministers had to come up with funds to make up for the lost / eliminated “tax rental agreement” revenue that funded provincial programmes.

Provincial governments made up for the lost federal revenue by creating, or dramatically raising, provincial sales taxes, instituting or raising fees for every imaginable service, from driver’s licenses to camp ground fees, along with instituting bridge and road tolls while looking to any other sources of revenue provincial Finance Ministers could come up with to make up for lost federal funding.

The major source of newfound provincial revenue: municipalities. If the federal government had download responsibility to the provinces for health care, housing, and post secondary education, provinces sought to gain revenue from the towns, villages and cities that filled the landscape of their provinces. All of a sudden, cities, towns and villages were almost entirely responsible for the provision of affordable and social housing, social programmes, child care, road construction and maintenance, and other infrastructure (sewers, provision of clean water), and any number of programmes previously almost the sole responsibility of the provinces.

Where senior levels of government may run deficit budgets, cities, towns and villages, school boards, and Vancouver’s Park Board are required to run an annual balanced budget. With responsibility for programmes previously funded by the province now the responsibility of municipalities, cities, town and villages scrambled to find the required revenue, which translated into: skyrocketing parking rates and extended paid parking hours, dramatically increased parking fines, and skyrocketing development permit fees for homeowners and developers alike — and, what is known as Community Amenity Contributions by developers paid to the city to fund child care centres, neighbourhood recreation centres, as well as social and affordable housing, and a variety of arts and other programmes.

Here, then — as may be seen in Councillor Boyle’s tweet above — was the dilemma faced by Mayor Kennedy Stewart and our City Councillors when, last week, together our elected civic leaders voted for a 6.35% property tax increase for 2022, to fund not just core programmes, but the programmes that determine the livability of our city, and also fulfill the election commitments made by the Mayor, the three Green Party City Councillors, and our OneCity and COPE Councillors. Last week, for Mayor Stewart and five of our Councillors, conscience won out over fiscal restraint.

#VanPoli | Vancouver City Council To Raise Property Taxes a Whopping 6.35%

In a contentious, multi-hour meeting of Vancouver City Council, in a split vote along party lines, with COPE’s Jean Swanson, OneCity Vancouver’s Christine Boyle, all three Green Party of Vancouver City Councillors — Pete Fry, Adriane Carr, and Michael Wiebe — voting to raise property taxes in the City of Vancouver in 2022 by a whopping 6.35%, with dissenting votes coming from the former Non-Partisan Association electeds on Council — Sarah Kirby-Yung, Lisa Dominato, Colleen Hardwick, Rebecca Bligh and Melissa De Genova —  arguing that Council should hold the line at a previously promised five per cent increase, at the end of a long and arduous day on Tuesday, reason and fiscal prudence did not win the day.

Next year’s highest in Metro Vancouver property tax increase will see much of the burden borne by small business owners as part of their triple net lease responsibilities, as well as landlords, and the much-put-upon homeowners across the city.

Among the more contentious parts of the debate was an amendment by Councillor Adriane Carr in which she introduced an additional $9 million per year in taxation to fund a variety of the city’s climate emergency goals.

It includes more money for more electric vehicle infrastructure, planting trees, and improving active transportation infrastructure, and comes two months after Council narrowly voted against funding similar measures through a new parking permit system. Councillor Rebecca Bligh said she supported the initiatives, but expressed concern only “some Council members” had been consulted in advance.

“It’s not popular not to support this (climate change measure), we’re likely to be called out on Twitter for not supporting this, and being called climate [change] deniers,” she told the media.

“The people who are going to vote for this, were engaged ahead of this meeting, and the people that likely are not going to vote for this, were not engaged at all.”

Vancouver City Council budget meeting on Tuesday, December 7 2021. Photo by Jason Payne /PNG

As Vancouver Sun civic affairs reporter Dan Fumano writes today

“Property taxes will rise 6.35% in the city of Vancouver after Council narrowly approved a 2022 budget on Tuesday. After a day of debate, Council passed a $1.747 billion operating budget, with a property tax increase higher than the five per cent proposed in last month’s draft budget. Most of the additional money goes to the police, fire department and climate measures.

On a proposed $9 million fund for the climate emergency measures, the five Councillors elected in 2018 with the Non-Partisan Association — Rebecca Bligh, Melissa De Genova, Lisa Dominato, Colleen Hardwick, and Sarah Kirby-Yung — voted no. It was one of several times Tuesday the five voted together. Four  have long since quit the NPA, citing concerns about its Board of Directors. Only De Genova is still with the NPA.

The other six Councillors, including the three Greens, one from OneCity, one COPE, and the independent mayor voted for the extra climate measures funding, with Stewart accusing the opponents of ignoring the climate emergency so evident in B.C. this year.”

Councillor Sarah Kirby-Yung reflecting on the shenanigans going on at Council’s budget meeting

In the hour prior to the taking of the final vote on the 2022 budget, VanRamblings was afforded the opportunity to speak with Councillor Kirby-Yung.

“All members of Council are dedicated climate change activists, recognize our climate emergency, and to date every member of Council has voted in favour of meaningful climate change policy when it has come before Council,” Kirby-Yung told VanRamblings.

“To, at the last minute, add a $9 million climate measure to a City budget already stretching at the seams — when tens, and over the years working in concert with senior levels of government, hundreds of millions of dollars has been set aside as the City’s response to our climate emergency represents for me, the height of fiscal irresponsibility, and as such emerges as a disservice to the already overtaxed residents of Vancouver.”

Non-Partisan Association City Councillor Melissa De Genova also weighed in.

Late Tuesday evening, Councillor Kirby-Yung tweeted out these thoughts …

Councillor Rebecca Bligh less than pleased with the ‘game playing’ of some of her Council colleagues (Photo courtesy of CBC photographer, Ben Nelms, and CBC civic affairs reporter Justin McElroy)

As CBC civic affairs reporter Justin McElroy writes

“Despite repeated motions in the last two years to try and keep the average property tax increase at five per cent or below, the $1.7 billion budget passed has an increase of 6.3 per cent. That works out to $72 for the average detached condo in the city, or $178 for the average home, not including parts of the property tax bill not under municipal control.”

Councillor Colleen Hardwick looks askance at a Council colleague during budget debate

Mr. McElroy then quotes Vancouver City Councillor Colleen Hardwick …

“The stark reality is we are just going ka-ching, ka-ching, ka-ching, ka-ching, and taking it not out of the one per cent, but of the middle-class people who are trying to afford to continue living in this city.” Hardwick said at one point. “I’m choked as I continue to see us add more and more. It was bad enough that we were looking at five per cent.”

Other than the climate measures included in the 2022 budget, some of the other increases that were not originally included in the draft budget included an extra $3.1 million to Vancouver Fire and Rescue Services for more firefighters, $670,000 for enhanced street cleaning, $1.2 million to fund the newly created Auditor General’s office, and additional funding to the Vancouver Police Department, allowing them to fill current vacancies and fund recent salary arbitration decisions.