#VanPoli | East, West | North, South | Vancouver | A Divided City

Vancouver voting patterns show an east-west and a north-south divide

In an article published in the Vancouver Sun on Monday, reporter Dan Fumano quotes urban geographer Aaron Licker as saying …

“We’re adding people in these areas (Fairview & Mount Pleasant) that vote for parties that want more density,” said Licker, whose company Licker Geospatial Consulting does work for clients including civic governments and real estate companies. “The NPA can play to the single-family homeowners (on the west side of the city) forever, but they’re declining in terms of population. Forty years ago, most of Vancouver lived in single-family areas, but now most of Vancouver lives in multi-family zones.”

Licker’s thesis: the old east side / west side divide that dictated electoral outcomes in Vancouver is no longer as relevant as the north-south divide.
To that end, Licker publishes the following graphic …

Voting patterns in Vancouver, says urban geographer Aaron Licker, suggests a north-south divide

While VanRamblings doesn’t dispute Licker’s thesis outright, we’re not so sure that his hypothesis — despite the graphic you see above — that it is the north-south divide, rather than the traditional east-west divide that is the determining factor in which neighbourhoods vote for which parties, and which Mayoral candidates.
According to the data we publish below — taken directly from the vancouver.ca website (take a look at the drop down menus to see how your neighbourhood voted, not just for Mayor but, if you scroll down, for Council, Park and School Board) — we’re not so sure that the east side-west side divide is quite as irrelevant as Mr. Licker would have us believe.

Voters on the east side of Vancouver vote overwhelmingly for Kennedy Stewart as MayorYou’ll note, almost universally, voters on Vancouver’s east side voted overwhelmingly for the progressive, VDLC-endorsed candidate for Mayor, Kennedy Stewart.

For the most part, the west side continues to vote in their class and monied interests, while the east side votes in their working class voter interests.

Voters on Vancouver's west side voted overwhelmingly for the business candidate for Mayor, Ken SimYou’ll note, almost universally, voters on Vancouver’s west side voted overwhelmingly for the right-of-centre business candidate for Mayor, Ken Sim.

Single family dwelling west side voters tend to want to pay less property tax, while east side voters want government to provide neighbourhood amenities, inject a bit of humanity into the decision-making at city hall, and acknowledge the diverse cultural & ethnic make-up of our neighbourhoods.
Never the twain shall meet?
The new Vancouver City Council has a palpable opportunity to break down class and economic barriers, and govern for the whole city, be prudent fiscal managers, while providing services to the community. Vancouverites have never voted for as diverse a Vancouver City Council, with an independent Mayor who is dedicated to broaching the divide, and a Council with elected members from five different political — when has that ever happened in our city previous to the October 20th election?
A political divide has opened on our political landscape that must be bridged
The answer: never. All of which means, it’s time for change in Vancouver politics. No more of this left-right, east-west, north-south divide — we see what that’s done to our neighbours to the south. Is that what we want in Vancouver, in Canada? Perhaps I’m naïve, but I think the answer is no.

#VanPoli | City Council | The First Day of the Rest of Their Lives

Mayor and Vancouver City Councillors group photo in Council chambers on inauguration dayVancouver’s new City Council meeting for the first time, l-r: Councillors Rebecca Bligh, Christine Boyle, Colleen Hardwick, Pete Fry, Adriane Carr & Mayor Kennedy Stewart + Councillors Melissa De Genova, Jean Swanson, Michael Wiebe, Lisa Dominato and Sarah Kirby-Yung, where in City Council chambers 10 motions will be presented for a vote

Tuesday, November 13th, 2018 marks the first day that the newly-elected Mayor and 10 City Councillors get down to business, with a raft of motions due to hit the floor, either in late morning, or after the lunch break — it’s going to be a busy day at Council (which doesn’t sit well with retired City Councillor George Affleck, as may be seen in his cautionary tweet below).

Retired Vancouver City Councillor George Affleck suggests new Council slow down

Even so, there’s work to be done, campaign promises to be kept, even if such does occur amidst the 30-day intensive orientation process to which our new Mayor & Councillors continue to be subject through December 7th.

Sarah Kirby-Yung, Day 6 of her and Mayor Kennedy Stewart & her fellow Councillors 30-day orientationDid we mention that former Park Board Chairperson Sarah Kirby-Yung is our favourite newly-elected City Councillor — which takes some doing, cuz we just sorta love all of our new City Councillors (and Mayor), and what a great communicator we’ve long known Councillor Kirby-Yung to be, and of how much she is on your side, and how much she wants work to “work across the aisle”, for you, to bring good governance to City Hall, as she knows our Mayor and all of our new City Councillors intend and will strive for …

At Tuesday’s first official “business meeting” of the new City Council, there are controversial motions, and some not quite so controversial.
On the relatively non-controversial side of the ledger (at least, let’s hope the motion emerges as non-controversial) is Councillor Pete Fry’s motion on the creation of A Renter’s Office at the City of Vancouver, long overdue, an idea that all three of our new Mayor, Kennedy Stewart, Councillor Fry, and Councillor Christine Boyle (who has seconded Mr. Fry’s motion) talked about on the campaign trail, and intend to represent the interests of renters.

Vancouver City Councillor Colleen Hardwick introduces motion to dump duplexes Councillor Colleen Hardwick’s motion seeks to eliminate duplexes across a large area of Vancouver currently zoned for single family residences. Duplexes: eliminating this form of “gentle density” ameliorates Vancouver’s affordable housing crisis how? The Straight


On the more controversial side of the ledger, unsurprisingly given what we know of the mover of the motion, there’s Councillor Colleen Hardwick’s motion to dump the duplex, which strangely and perversely seems to have some support on both sides of the aisle at City Hall, the near unanimous “duplex motion” passed by the previous Council designed as one of many measures to create “gentle density” and increased affordability in single family neighbourhoods throughout the city (full disclosure: VanRamblings’ daughter, husband and two grandson’s live in & own a duplex in Kitsilano).
Before continuing, VanRamblings’ readers may want to look at Jennifer Bradshaw & Albert Huang article in The Straight, which reads in part …

“Duplexes were the first step city staff recommended under the last council toward increasing “missing middle” multifamily homes in the city, as part of an affordable housing plan. Before this, all multifamily homes, including duplexes, rowhouses, social and co-op homes, were banned on 75 percent of Vancouver land, and only the most expensive type of home, single-detached houses (historically known as “single-family houses”) were allowed.

The new councillor’s move to reinstate the ban on duplexes is the polar opposite of the direction Vancouver should be going for …”

At the very least, response to Councillor Hardwick’s motion oughta be interesting (which, as we all know, constitutes the old Chinese curse).

58 West Hastings, what it could and was designed to be, and what it is in 2018Social Housing. 58 West Hastings. What the site could be (left), what it is now (right).

Again, before continuing, it’s worth reading Nathan Crompton, Steffanie Ling and Caitlin Shane’s June 19, 2018 column, Battle for 58 West Hastings: Broken Promises and Co-optation in The Mainlander.
Here’s the bottom line: after years of activism by Jean Swanson, Wendy Pedersen, Ivan Drury, residents of the Downtown Eastside, and activists citywide, in 2011 Gregor Robertson and the members of his Vision Vancouver Council team “purchased” 58 West Hastings from developer Concord Pacific, swapping 58 West Hastings for another site at 117 East Hastings. Soon after the swap, on the steps of the Carnegie Centre, Mayor Robertson announced that it was his intention and the intention of Council to develop 130 units of social housing on the 58 West Hastings site.
Seven years on, regrettably and egregiously no such work has begun, as Vancouver’s homelessness housing (and opioid) crisis continues to burgeon.
To begin the process of addressing that appalling situation, at Council on Tuesday, newly-elected Vancouver City Councillor Jean Swanson will introduce a motion to “recommit (Council) to the community vision of 100% welfare / pension rate community controlled social housing and the former Mayor’s promise for the site at 58 West Hastings Street.”
Now, there are seven more motions that are due to come before Council on Tuesday, ranging from a motion by Councillor Swanson to protect woebegone renters from renovictions and aggressive buy-outs by developers, to a motion by Mayor Kennedy Stewart to strike an emergency opoioid task force, all of which motions (and more) may be found here.

Newly-elected Vancouver Mayor and City Councillors in chambers, November 2018Here they are: your new Mayor & City Councillors, in chambers and ready to get to work

Vancouver City Council meetings are live streamed here, and are available online afterwards. Tuesday’s Vancouver City Council meeting will begin at 9:30am, with all of our electeds chipper, in place and set to get to work.
This is your city, folks, and your new Vancouver City Council — who mean to do well for us. It’s worth taking a boo at the work in which our new Mayor and Council mean to engage, to break down your sense of isolation, anomie and cynicism, and to engender hope for our future.

The Music of One’s Life, The Gift of Music from My Son

From the late 1960s on, I have been gifted with having a series of publications publish my music reviews. My love for music started much earlier than that, though — in all likelihood, probably from the womb, because my mother loved music, our home filled always with the popular music of the day, which seemed to give my mother life, and succeeded almost always in bringing joy into our home.
The gift of the love of music was passed on to my children, by both their mother and me, both of us from an early age finding succour and sustenance in music that embedded itself into the lifeblood of our lives.
My son, Jude Nathan Tomlin, extended our family’s love of music beyond mere singing in the home, or playing music on the home or car stereo: Jude makes music, and has traveled the world as a progressive house D.J., playing his own special brand of house music. Most, if not all of his music collection is on vinyl, because he (and many others) experience the sound of music that emanates from vinyl as fuller, warmer and more intimate.
Over the years, every now and then, Jude would run across a piece of music that was not intended to be digitized, and had not been digitized, but as he knew that almost all of my music is either on CD, DVD or mp3, Jude would take pity on his poor dad and convert the vinyl “song” he had discovered into a high quality mp3 to add to my music collection (although he’d find the juxtaposing of the words “high quality” and “mp3” a curious construction indeed, and mutually exclusive concepts … still and all …).
Even today, I could not find Transglobal Underground’s remix of Dub Tribal’s Elastic Reality anywhere as an mp3, or on YouTube, so I uploaded the “song”, which you’ll find at the top of today’s Music Sunday column.
I recall one day not all that many years ago, when Jude arrived home from his travels, his sitting down at my computer, whereupon he added Transglobal Underground’s remix of Dub Tribal’s Elastic Reality to my iTunes music collection, and subsequently to my iPhone’s 5000+ song collection of music. I find the song calming, as does Jude, and as he knew I would.
Jude continues often, if less often than previously, to provide me with the gift of music, as he did some years ago with the second song on today’s Music Sunday roster, an historical piece of music by The Art of Noise, featuring the late British actor John Hurt performing the narrative vocal, the song about Claude Debussy, titled, The Holy Egoism Of Genius.

Stories of a Life | Is Raymond Jewish? | Yep, Certainly by Blood

In the early part of the 20th century, my grandfather escaped the Ukrainian pogroms, an ethnic cleansing of the Jewish population that was taking place across eastern Europe1903: In the early part of the 20th century, my grandfather escaped the Ukrainian pogroms, an ethnic cleansing of the Jewish population that was taking place across eastern Europe that resulted in the murder of tens of thousands of Jews.

Whether it be the 11 congregants at Pittsburgh’s Tree of Life synagogue who were wantonly murdered only two short weeks ago, or Jews being targeted in the alt-right rally in Charlottesville on August 11th and 12th of 2017, or the 907 Jewish refugees escaping Hitler’s Germany in 1939 who were refused safe harbour in both Canada and the United States, most of the 907 returning to their deaths in Europe, where six million more Jews were slaughtered during the course of WWII, or the fact that since 2015 hate crimes in Canada against people of the Jewish faith has risen by an astonishing 30%, the fact of the Jewish diaspora and the murder over the centuries of hundreds of thousands of Jews as “the other” in countries across the globe is a devastating and unjust historical fact for the ages.

Pogrom of 1819 in Frankfurt, GermanyThe Hep-Hep riots in Frankfurt, Germany in 1819 that occurred amidst a climate of anti-Semitism fueled by various anti-Jewish publications. Participants in these riots rallied to the cry, “Hepp Hepp”, which may have been an acronym for “Hierosolyma est perdita”, meaning “Jerusalem is lost”. On the left, two peasant women are assaulting a Jewish man with pitchfork and broom. On the right, a man wearing spectacles, tails and a six-button waistcoat, “perhaps a pharmacist or a schoolteacher,” holds another Jewish man by the throat and is about to club him with a truncheon. The houses are being looted.

First recorded in 1882, the Russian word pogrom is derived from the common prefix po- and the verb gromit’ meaning “to destroy, to wreak havoc, to demolish violently” — apparently a word borrowed from Yiddish, the term first used to describe the anti-Semitic excesses in the Russian Empire from 1881 — 1883. Antisemitism in the Ukraine has been a historical issue, as well, but became more widespread in the 20th century.
Pogroms were a generational fact of life in the Ukraine, in 1821, 1859, 1871, 1881, 1903 and 1905, across the whole of the Ukraine.
In 1903, when my grandfather was but a young Jewish teenage boy, he managed to escape the Odessa pogroms that killed thousands that year, making his way by foot to Sweden, where he hoped to find passage to Canada. Word had filtered into Europe at the turn of the last century that the Canadian government was offering tracts of land to European settlers, and it was with this fact in mind that my grandfather set about to make his way to Canada, fully aware that Jews were not included in the Canadian government’s offer of land in exchange for breadbasket farming development, in the hope of settling the Prairie provinces, and making Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba part of the new country of Canada.

Ship transporting Jews from Europe to Canada at the turn of the last century

While in Sweden, my grandfather married a young Jewish woman he met while awaiting passage, and not many months later the two were boarded onto a ship sailing out of Sweden for Canada, arriving in our burgeoning new country in the spring of 1905. Irrespective of the laws of the time, and because the new province of Alberta was desperate to have their land settled, my grandparents were provided a densely treed tract, a full section of land just outside of what we now know as High River, Alberta. Over the years, one section of land grew into many, 10 children were born, five boys and five girls, the last of whom was my mother, born on March 28th, 1924.
The life was hardscrabble, even more so upon the death of my grandmother in the early winter of 1927, when my mother was but three years of age. All the children pitched in, though, creating a thriving farm — up until the Great Depression of the 1930s. By the time my mother was twelve years of age, she had struck out on her own, making a life for herself as a waitress in Drumheller, Alberta, a job she held off and on for the next fourteen years. World War II saw her moving to Vancouver to work first in the shipyards, and then in the factories making armaments — factory work a staple of her life for the next 35 years.
In 1946, my mother Mary met my father Jack, the two were married, and in 1947 my brother Robert was born, a sickly child who died three months after his birth. Escaping grief, my parents moved to Drumheller, where my mother had friends, and where her old waitress job awaited her, my father picking up what work he could. On August 9th, 1950, my mother went into labour, and had my father drive the both of them back over the deadly Rocky Mountain pass, the two arriving in Vancouver and driving directly to Vancouver General Hospital, where I was born at 2:26pm on Friday, August 11th, 1950. My sister Linda was born a bit less than two years later at St. Paul’s Hospital, on May 29th, 1952. My mother had insisted that both her children be born in Vancouver — to know my mother is to know that no one ever refused her. To this day, I am attracted only, and have found myself in loving relationships with tough, take no guff, opinionated (and, dare I say, “crazy” and just a tad, or more than a tad, mentally unstable — and, yes, I realize that’s sorta like the pot calling the kettle black … even so) women.

Jewish family, early 1950s

For the first 20 years of my life, the fact of my Jewishness was never raised with either my sister or me, not by my parents, not by my “spinster” aunt Freda (Blackerman, my mother’s maiden name), nor my aunt Anne and Uncle Dave, my uncle Joe nor any of my mother’s Jewish brothers and sisters — the quid pro quo in my family was that if my aunts, uncles and cousins wanted me to be a part of their lives, there was to be no talk of my Jewish heritage — this edict by my mother extended as well to my tall oak of a grandfather, who was every bit the sophisticated patrician Jew.
Every Sunday of our youth, my sister and I were picked up by a small school bus and transported to Sunday school, spending the rest of the day being taken to lunch, swimming, out to Stanley Park, or otherwise engaged by the members of the church. Every week I memorized and recited verses from the New Testament at Sunday school.
Now, there were some “hints” given that I might be Jewish — my mother, when she wasn’t working at one of her three jobs, loved to bake, and I grew up on a steady diet of Jewish pastries, my favourite the jam-infused hamantaschen, and jam, nut and raisin-infused rugelach, which latter small pastries I could consume by the dozen.
Growing up there was a great deal of arguing that went on between my parents, epithets thrown at my mother by my father, with the words “dirty Jew” heard on the other side of the door inside of my parent’s bedroom, words raged at my mother by my father. Otherwise, although I suspected I was Jewish, the fact was never confirmed for me growing up.

Simon Fraser University's Louis Riel House, a student family one-and-two-bedroom apartmentSimon Fraser University’s Louis Riel House, student family 1 + 2 bedroom residence

At around 10am one summer’s morning in July, 1972, while we were resident at Louis Riel House, Cathy and I received a telephone call from a woman identifying herself as my “Aunt Sally.” I took pains to explain to her that she must have the wrong number, that I had no “Aunt Sally”, to which she replied …

“I am your Aunt Sally. Your mother is Mary, who is my youngest sister. Your Aunt Freda — who all but raised you — is my second youngest sister. Summer’s you went to stay with your Auntie Anne, my sister, and your Uncle Dave, in Lethbridge. When you were younger, you stayed on my father’s farm in High River, Alberta. You know my older brother, Joe — who, when you lived in Edmonton for Grades 4, 5 and 6, helped to raise you when your mother was working three jobs, and your father was working evenings at the Post Office. Believe me when I say, Raymond — I am your Aunt Sally.”

At which point, my newly-discovered Aunt Sally invited Cathy and I for lunch at the Bayshore Inn where she and her husband, Alex (Promislow) were staying while in town, on a mission to make contact with me. Aunt Sally told me that she’d already made arrangements with my mother to join us for lunch, and she expected Cathy and I to arrive at noon, where she would greet us at the entrance to The Bayshore.

Westin Bayshore Inn, Vancouver, circa 1972

Lunch was good, my mother remaining all but mute throughout the meal.
I met my Uncle Alex, Sally’s husband — who years earlier had secured the distribution rights for Lee’s jeans in Canada, a percentage of each pair of jeans, and other Lee’s products, placed into his bank account, making him a wealthy man. I heard all about my aunt, now living in Calgary, spending the early part of her life, after leaving home, in Winnipeg, where she’d met Alex. I was given the Five Books of Moses, and was provided with a more in-depth history of my family, dating back centuries, than I ever could have hoped for. Through it all, my mother denied her Jewishness — she readily admitted that Sally was her sister, but insisted she had been adopted, and had not a drop of Jewish blood in her, and as an atheist had never been a member of any church, never mind a synagogue, which notion she told us she found offensive and off-putting, her so-called “heritage” a complete and utter lie. My aunt Sally simply rolled her eyes, and harrumphed a bit.
I stayed in touch with my aunt Sally and Uncle Alex for another 15 years, but eventually lost touch with the both of them.

Jewish Community Centre, Vancouver

Growing up, I apprised both Jude and Megan of their Jewish heritage — much to their mother’s chagrin, my children’s mother both anti-religion and an avowed atheist. Hanukkah, one of the lesser Jewish holidays, was their favourite, occurring as it did in December, and generally just before Christmas. Jude and Megan loved receiving one small gift each day of Hanukkah, and enjoyed lighting the menora, as well. We always attended cultural celebrations at the Jewish Community Centre, dancing up a storm.
Jude and Megan had Jewish friends, and attended at various bat and bar mitzvahs, but did not have one of their own (their mother would have had a conniption fit!). During Passover, we were invited to friend’s homes for Seder, at which time our Jewish friends explained the importance of Passover, and what it meant to people of the Jewish faith.
I have come to believe that the immense amount of energy that I have brought to the tasks of my life — as is the case with my daughter, who possesses the same capacity as me to work days on end with little or no sleep, while maintaining both a high energy and output level — derives from the Jewish blood that courses through my veins. For my children, their Jewishness is not a factor in their lives, as is the case with my grandsons.
Still, I consider myself to be Jewish — my mother was Jewish, and Judaism is a matriarchy, so I am very much a Jew, even if my mother denied her Jewish heritage to her dying day. For my younger sister Linda, her Jewish heritage plays no role in her life, nor in that of my two nieces.
I have decided to take classes with Rabbi Dan Moskovitz in the new year to become better acquainted with my heritage — a bit late in my life, but better late than never. And, of course, at the invitation of my friend Jacob Kojfman, I will once again attend the Dreidels & Drinks Hanukkah celebration, for me the low-key, warmly inviting, edifying and humane event of the holiday season, to which are invited every federal, provincial and Metro Vancouver elected official, providing an opportunity to converse and interact across political boundaries (the number of political figures I introduced to one another, avowed “enemies” at first introduction, and only a few minutes later best of friends, person after person approaching me to say, “Thank you for that introduction, Raymond — who’d have thought that —- and I had so much in common? We got along famously!”

Dreidels & Drinks Hanukkah celebration in Vancouver

And, really, when you get right down to it, isn’t that what the holiday season is all about — peace, love, understanding, brother-and-sisterhood.