Over the past weekend, VanRamblings had the opportunity to speak with a senior member of British Columbia’s public health pandemic response team, and the information with which we were provided was hopeful for B.C.’s near term future.
“British Columbia has entered the endemic phase of what we’ve all come to know as the pandemic this past 19 months, in fact, some while ago,” our unnamed source, unauthorized to speak on behalf of the office of British Columbia’s Public Health Office, told VanRamblings. “We’re not far off from removing mask mandates in those areas of the province where the full vaccination rate exceeds 90%, as is the case in Vancouver city proper, where the rate of fully vaccinated persons is currently 95% plus. Other regions of the province — Fraser Valley East, the Interior and Northern Health — have a ways to go before mask mandates, and other restrictions are removed by British Columbia’s public health office.”
VanRamblings asked the individual with whom we spoke about the current high COVID-19 infection rates we’re experiencing in British Columbia — most recently, the 3rd highest in Canada — and how this phenomenon might be accounted for …
“In British Columbia, we’re experiencing a series of super spreader events brought on by the unvaccinated members of regional communities, mostly situated in the three regions of the province where vaccination rates are low. Fully 98% of all COVID-19 hospitalizations and admissions to hospital ICU’s has occurred either within the unvaccinated community, or resultant from vulnerable vaccinated persons coming into contact with unvaccinated persons,” avers our public health source.
VanRamblings was told that in all likelihood British Columbians will be out of the worst of COVID-19 — even given the current and deadly virulence of the Delta variant — by early spring 2022, when life will return to some sense of “normal”, as we’ve all been observing now with capacity restrictions being lifted at Vancouver Canucks home games, within movie theatre complexes, and even at concerts.
When we asked our source about the 327 doctors, nurses and other health care professionals in British Columbia who have yet to get their first mRNA vaccine dose, our source simply rolled their eyes, muttering …
“As a health care professional, you are a scientist. Why you wouldn’t acknowledge the science on vaccines is beyond me? To say the least, that unfortunate development is disappointing, for those of us in the profession, and for all British Columbians.”
Or, as British Columbia Public Health Officer Dr. Bonnie Henry stated on Monday …
Health care is "probably not the right profession" for workers who don't recognize the importance of vaccines, Dr. Bonnie Henry said Monday.
On balance, it is probable that the comfort level for most of us in the general public will not be alleviated until infection, hospitalization and ICU rates are observed as being significantly reduced, with COVID-19 death rates all but eliminated on most reporting days, and the rate of death from COVID-19 in B.C. minimal at worst.
Not all infectious disease terms are created equal, though often they’re mistakenly used interchangeably.
The distinction between the words “pandemic,” “epidemic,” and “endemic” is often blurred, even by doctors. This is because the definition of each term is fluid and changes as diseases become more or less prevalent over time.
The word “endemic” is regularly mentioned, especially among public health leaders and experts as they discuss potential future scenarios. So, it’s important to define exactly what it would mean for COVID to be endemic.
Scientists predict COVID will become endemic over time but there will still be sporadic outbreaks where it gets out of control. The transition from pandemic to endemic will play out differently in different locations around the world.
While conversational use of these words might not require precise definitions, knowing the difference is important to help all of us better understand public health news and appropriate public health responses.
First let’s recap the public health terms Canadians have been increasingly using in conversation over the last 19 months. These words cover the lifecycle of disease and include “outbreak”, “epidemic”, “pandemic” and “endemic”.
An outbreak is a rise in disease cases over what is normally expected in a small and specific location generally over a short period of time, as occurred in Wuhan, China in late 2019 and early 2020. Food borne diseases caused by Salmonella contamination provides another example of the outbreak phenomena.
A pandemic is an epidemic that spreads across many countries & continents around the world, as has been the case with COVID-19 over the course of the past 19 months. Past pandemic examples include those caused by influenza A(H1N1) or the “Spanish Flu” in 1918, HIV/AIDS, SARS-CoV-1 and the Zika virus.
What’s the usual path from pandemic to endemic?
A simple way to understand the difference between an epidemic and a pandemic is to remember the “P” in pandemic, which means a pandemic has a passport. A pandemic is an epidemic that travels.
But what’s the difference between epidemic and endemic?
An epidemic is actively spreading; new cases of the disease far exceed what is expected. More broadly, it’s used to describe any problem that’s out of control, such as “the opioid epidemic.”
An epidemic is localized to a region, but the number of those infected is significantly higher than normal. For example, when COVID-19 was limited to Wuhan, China, it was an epidemic. The geographical spread turned it into a pandemic.
Endemics, on the other hand, are a constant presence in a specific location. Malaria is endemic to parts of Africa. Ice is endemic to Antarctica.
Over time and arising from public health orders from mask wearing to vaccination, the pandemic could disappear like small pox and polio did — or it might gradually become endemic. The latter, most scientists agree, is the more likely scenario. Host, environment and virus factors combine to explain why some viruses are endemic while others are epidemic.
When we look at the SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes COVID, we see it is infecting human hosts with no prior immunity.
In terms of environment, the virus transmits better in cold, dry, crowded, close-contact, confined settings with poor ventilation. Each virus has its own characteristics, from speed of virus replication to drug resistance. The new COVID strains are transmitted faster and cause different symptoms.
Viruses are more likely to become endemic if they become adapted to a local environment and/or have a continuous supply of susceptible hosts. For COVID these would be hosts with low or zero immunity.
How long will it take for COVID-19 to become an endemic?
Most public health officials currently agree COVID is here to stay rather than likely to disappear like small pox. Scientific mathematical modelling provides some idea of likely COVID epidemic outcomes.
Globally, the road from pandemic to endemic will be a rocky one.
In Canada, the federal government and provincial Premiers some time ago announced plans to re-open businesses, and soon that will be the case with borders, as well. The process of having done this has worked out better in some provinces than others. In the prairie provinces of Alberta and Saskatchewan, the fourth wave of COVID has taken a particularly strong foothold — resulting in a virulent and devastating epidemic renewal of COVID.
People are dying, and our health care system has been challenged.
Vaccination rates will protect many — as will the vaccine passports that have been issued in all provinces across the country — but there are still those who won’t get vaccinated, which puts all of us at much greater risk.
With time, though, scientists predict COVID will become more like the common cold coronaviruses. Despite periodic spikes in caseloads each season or immediately after relaxation of economic, social, and travel restrictions, COVID will eventually become more manageable, and by next spring we could very well be out of the worst of COVID-19, and the worst impacts of the Delta variant.
Countries will not enter an endemic phase at the same time because of variable host, environmental, virus factors including vaccination rates. Because of Canada’s high vaccination rate, our country is much more likely to proceed to the endemic stage than our neighbours to the south.
The availability and roll-out of booster vaccine shots each year or season will also shape the path towards the transition to an endemic. Poor vaccine coverage could allow the virus to continue at an epidemic level for longer — as would appear to be the case in the northern health, Fraser Valley East and Interior / Okanagan and Kootenay regions of our province.
Once we see a stable level of SARS-CoV-2 transmission indicating a new “baseline” of COVID, we will know the pandemic has ended and the virus is endemic. This will include seasonal trends as we see now with flu, and next autumn a dual flu and COVID shot, currently being developed by Pfizer and NovaVax.
The most important thing all of us can do to help reach a safe level of endemic COVID is to ensure that our families and each of us gets vaccinated and that we continue to adhere to COVID-safe practices, like social distancing, mask wearing and staying home when we’re not feeling well.
By doing so we protect ourselves, our families, all those around us, as together we move collectively towards an endemic phase of the COVID-19 virus that has had us in its grip since March 2020.
If we fail to work together in common cause, things could turn for the worse very quickly and prolong the end of the pandemic — which none of us want.
There he stood, morning in, morning out for a year. A whole year. Reassuring the nation that all would be fine. Standing in front of his Rideau Cottage home, his beard growing longer with each passing day, his wife herself, initially, a victim of COVID-19, leaving him to care for his children alone while his wife Sophie self-isolated, a father to his three children and Canada’s father in a time of despair.
On March 11, 2020, the World Heath Organization declared that the world was in the grip of a once-in-a-century pandemic that would kill millions, no vaccines yet existed to fight off this killer, and to protect us, lockdowns would be required that would keep us inside our homes for weeks and months on end.
Businesses across Canada were shuttered, no one went outside without wearing a mask — once a week shopping for necessities would be approved, but little else.
In addition to the health crisis that jeopardized our collective health, nations across the globe faced an economic crisis the likes of which we’d never known. On March 18, 2020, on the orders of British Columbia’s Public Health Officer, Dr. Bonnie Henry, the province declared a State of Emergency.
On March 16th, 2020, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced that until further notice, Canadian borders would be closed to foreign nationals — urging Canadians abroad to return home as soon as possible, given the ever-tighter travel restrictions countries around the world – including Canada – were imposing to curb the spread of the new coronavirus, stating that before the end of the month, the federal government would disallow the opportunity given Canadians to return home.
Canada was in a crisis, as the COVID-19 pandemic led to a dramatic loss of human life worldwide, presenting an unprecedented challenge to public health, food systems and the world of work, causing economic and social disruption, devastating the lives of millions of Canadians at risk of falling into poverty.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announces $82 billion rescue plan | March 18, 2020
The Liberal government and Justin Trudeau — working in concert with Health Minister Patti Hajdu and Minister of Public Services and Procurement, Anita Anand, among other Ministers — mounted a massive and efficacious response to the pandemic, quarterbacking an unprecedented campaign against the threat of the virus and lockdowns that had shaken the economy, legislating a blitz of new and necessary programmes designed to keep Canadians safe, and economically whole.
March 15, 2020. Ottawa commits $2 billion to buy supplies, purchasing tens of millions of masks, and thousands of testing kits and ventilators from Canadian-based manufacturers, who shifted production to make the badly needed equipment and supplies.
March 16, 2020. Canada announces plans to close the border to international travel. The Canada-U.S. border closes to non-essential travel, with exceptions for truckers and a few other groups. A mandatory self-quarantine for travelers. Anyone returning to Canada legally required to self-quarantine for 14 days.
March 18, 2020. Government announces an aid package providing economic benefits for Canadians affected by COVID-19, the programme fleshed out in subsequent days & benefits increased.
March 25, 2020. The Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) announced, providing $500 per week in financial support to employed and self-employed Canadians affected by COVID-19. Minimum Employment Insurance benefit increased to $500 weekly. Canada Recovery Sickness Benefit of $500 per week for workers who’d contracted COVID-19. Canada Recovery Caregiving Benefit of $500 per week to support families with children six years of age, or younger, and to support low-income workers and families. Mortgage Deferral Payment provided to homeowners facing financial hardship. Old Age Security pensioners receive one-time $500 tax-free benefit.
March 27, 2020. For businesses in Canada: The Canada Emergency Wage Subsidy provided to employers, to keep employees on payroll during the COVID-19 pandemic. The Canada Emergency Rent Subsidy to provide rent / mortgage subsidy to qualifying businesses, including charities and non-profits. Relief measures for Indigenous businesses, providing $306.8 million to small and medium-sized Indigenous businesses, and to support Aboriginal Financial Institutions that offer financing to these important businesses.
August 31, 2020. Justin Trudeau’s Liberal government signs contracts with Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna to procure more than 100 million doses of their experimental COVID‑19 vaccines, signing contracts with Johnson & Johnson (Janssen), Novavax and AstraZenica/Covashield for 80 million more doses. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau also announces funding to establish a new biomanufacturing facility at the Human Health Therapeutics Research Centre in Montréal, and two other biomanufacturing facilities, in western Canada and Ontario, approved by the National Research Council of Canada to increase vaccine manufacturing of up to four million doses per month, to ensure Canada’s ability to produce sufficient vaccine doses to meet our country’s need.
The federal programmes and actions above barely scratch the surface of the response by Justin Trudeau’s Liberal government — which set out to provide health, social and economic support for every Canadian, and support for every sector of the economy. The critically important programmes enacted by the Justin Trudeau-led Liberal government were and are unprecedented anywhere across the globe.
Little wonder, then, that going into this election, Justin Trudeau’s personal approval rating was in the high 80s, and support for his government at 45%.
The rhetoric you’re likely to hear from an Erin O’Toole Conservative government
Ask yourself: given the chaos Canadians have witnessed in the anti-science Conservative government-led provinces of Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Ontario, what is the potential that an Erin O’Toole-led government would have responded to this once-in-a-century pandemic any better than we’ve witnessed in those four anti-science Conservative provinces — where each of their leaders have record low approval ratings — or we saw in Donald Trump’s COVID denialism (and we witness in today’s federal Conservative party Trump acoloyte caucus)?
“It’ll just disappear one day. It’ll go away like all things go away,” Trump said. “I feel about vaccines like I feel about tests. COVID will go away without a vaccine, just go away, and we’re not going to see it again. It’ll be gone, like it was never here. You have my word on it.”
The 44th Canadian general election is the most volatile election in our nation’s history. Both Conservative Party leader Erin O’Toole, and New Democratic Party leader Jagmeet Singh have together employed American, Republican-style politicking, unprecedented in Canadian history that a right wing and (allegedly) left wing party would collude on their campaign messaging to “gain power” …
“Justin Trudeau is a liar,” say O’Toole and Singh. “He’s not done a damn thing for you. He’s a smarmy, self-righteous, virtue signalling fraud who trots out the same — still unfulfilled — campaign promises he did in 2015 and 2019. He can’t be trusted, he’s not on your side. Vote for me. I’ve got your back. Throw that Justin Trudeau onto the scrap heap of history. He’s done. It’s time for a new day.”
Don’t you believe any of the malarkey above that’s being spewed out by Erin O’Toole and Jagmeet Singh. You know better. You’ve witnessed Justin Trudeau advocate for us, and over the course of these past 19 months, Mr. Trudeau — and his incredibly competent and hard-working, principled Ministers of the Crown — have sacrificed for us, and provided for us each and every day, keeping us all safe.
Please don’t allow Erin O’Toole’s and Jagmeet Singh’s cynical politics of personal destruction cause Canadians to indulge a sense of collective amnesia, and not recognize that, indeed, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is a Canadian national hero. We would not have pulled through the worst of the COVID-19 pandemic were any other Canadian leader in place. Justin Trudeau as Canadian Prime Minister remains critical to our national health, our ability to prevail in this pandemic, and to our national identity as Canadians working in common cause for the benefit of all.
Quite simply — and you know it’s true — there is no other Canadian political leader (and certainly not Erin O’Toole or Jagmeet Singh) capable of returning each one of us to the lives we led prior to the pandemic, ever more emboldened that we found the strength and the wherewithall to make it through this tragedy, and come out the other end all the better, more fulfilled personally and economically, with a greater wealth of spirit, and a sense of joy to inform all of our days yet to come.
