Category Archives: Vancouver

#ParkBoard | The Politics Never End Within Our Civic Bodies

John Coupar - current Vancouver Park Board CommissionerJohn Coupar, Non Partisan Association Park Board Commissioner | Standing in opposition to an anti-democratic motion coming to the Vancouver Park Board | Photo: Dan Toulgoet

In civic governance as practiced within the City of Vancouver, politics — you know, the kind of politics that have our electeds sniping at, belittling, attempting to one up, disliking verging on hatred, while actively engaged in disrespecting one another — remains the order of the day, less so at Vancouver School Board, but ever present at Council (or, now, during their safe socially distanced Webex online meetings), and around the Park Board table nestled within the Vancouver Park Board offices, or is now the case during our pandemic times, online using the city’s Webex online platform.
In the new year, VanRamblings will dedicate the early months of the year to writing about Vancouver civic governance (suffice to say, we’re not happy), and had intended to enjoy the season and leave for another day what will in all likelihood be an evisceration (such a nasty word) of governance in the city of Vancouver, as it is currently practiced, until the following arose …

Vancouver Park Board Procedural Motion, December 7 2020

Vancouver Park Board staff will bring the above recommendation to the Park Board table next Monday, December 7th, first in an in-camera online meeting not available to the public, and then at 6:30pm when the final online meeting of Park Board Commissioners — before the holiday break — will take place. The next Park Board meeting is set for January 18th, 2021.
According to a 31-page Vancouver Park Board staff report [PDF] …

The Vancouver Board of Parks and Recreation Procedure By-law (Park Board Procedure By-law) guides how the business of the Park Board Commissioners is handled and applies to all meetings of the Board and its committees. While the current by-law underwent a comprehensive review in 2018 before being enacted by the Board January 2019, it is best practice to undertake regular administrative reviews to ensure procedures remain relevant.

The revisions outlined in this report, and attached as Appendix A, are proposed to reflect current practices, address gaps, and clarify procedures that may have led to some ambiguity or confusion. Additionally, recommendations have been included to provide Commissioners options to follow-up on the “Future Considerations noted in the last by-law update report regarding electronic and special meetings.

The net impact of the recommendation, when it becomes a motion before the Board this next Monday, as it surely will, would be to deny a minority contingent of duly elected Park Board members to call a Special Meeting of the Board to seek public input on issues of concern to the general populace.
In these parts, we call that bullying, rule of the majority, arrogant decision-making by elected officials, and - let’s face it - downright anti-democratic.

Vancouver Park Board Commissioners, 2018 - 2022Vancouver Park Board Commissioners, l-r: Tricia Barker, John Coupar (NPA); Gwen Giesbrecht, John Irwin (COPE); Stuart Mackinnon, Camil Dumont, Dave Demers (Greens)

Apparently, the genesis for the staff recommendation arises from a Special Meeting of the Board that two Commissioners, John Coupar and Tricia Barker, called this past summer to discuss transportation issues within Stanley Park, with which members of the public had expressed concern.
As a general rule — be it at Council, School Board or Park Board — senior staff are reluctant, at best, to meet with the public to discuss issues of public concern, cuz it’s messy and democratic, and diminishes their power as the professionals who, in actuality, “run” city governance — not to mention which, these time consuming meetings can go on for days, and it takes them away from the familial comfort of their homey and cozy offices.
Park Board staff were none-too-pleased with the calling of the June 18, 2020 Special Meeting — thus, their recommendation to Commissioners. And, if truth be told, neither were COPE Commissioners Gwen Giesbrecht — who viscerally dislikes the rather lovable John Coupar — and John Irwin, and Green Party of Vancouver Park Board Commissioners, current Chairperson, Camil Dumont (also not much of a fan of his NPA Park Board colleagues, ditto his fellow Greens) — Dave Demers & Stuart Mackinnon.
Yes, it’s civic governance as a particularly bad high school experience.

Vancouver Park Board office, on Beach Avenue north-west of English Bay

Now, should the staff “recommendation” be accepted by a majority of the Board at this upcoming final 2020 meeting of Park Board, here’s what the net effect the passage of the motion would mean for governance at the Board, as well as the process to realize the intention of Park Board staff …

1. Going forward only the Park Board Chairperson, or a majority of Board members could call for a Special Meeting of the Board — a derivation of Board practice dating back to its inception more than a century ago;

2. Although there is a provision in the by-law and Park Board governance provisions that would allow a minority contingent of Park Board Commissioners to call a Special Meeting, to address urgent issues of concern to the public, such a motion could (and probably would) be tabled by the majority of the Board Commissioners, effectively making moot the urgent concern provisions of Park Board governance;

3. Assuming the “motion” passes, it would then be forwarded to Vancouver City Council for passage before Council (where such provisions as staff are recommending at Park Board are already in place). How would Council likely respond to the entreaty of Park Board to make application to the provincial government for a change to the Vancouver Charter to accommodate the expressed wishes of the current Park Board? VanRamblings believes the answer would be, contentiously not well;

4. For the sake of argument, let’s say Council says, “Okay you buckos at Park Board, we’ll grant you your Christmas wish, and post your recommended Charter change to our mistresses and masters in Victoria.” La-di-dah. How would British Columbia’s new Minister Responsible for Municipal Affairs, former Tofino Mayor, Josie Osborne, receive the entreaty of Council and Park Board for a change to the Vancouver Charter?

Uuummmm, not well?

One would think that our currently elected Park Board Commissioners would have many better things to do with their time than to seek to diminish democratic governance around the Park Board table, and diminish input from the public into decision-making by our elected Commissioners.
Apparently not.

Vancouver Park Board Commissioner John Coupar on his opposition to a motion to be presented at Park Board on December 7 2020 that would limit public input into decision-making at the Park Board table, and prevent minority members of the Board from calling for a Special Meeting of the Board when issues of public concern arise.

Note should be made that Park Board Chair Dumont determines what items find their way onto the Park Board agenda — as it happens, the Park Board Chair is all powerful. Nothing gets onto the agenda if he doesn’t want it to. So, apparently, Mr. Dumont is possessed of a strong desire to see this staff recommendation become a motion at the Park Board table, a motion he would vigorously support and urge his fellow Commissioners to support.

Green Party of Vancouver Park Board Chairperson, Camil Dumont

‘Ceptin one thing: at some point, it’s possible that Mr. Dumont and Mr. Demers would comprise a minority contingent of Green Party of Vancouver Park Board Commissioners on the elected Vancouver Park Board, the values of the remaining Park Board Commissioners in diametric opposition to that for which Mr. Dumont and Mr. Demers steadfastly stand.
Note to Park Board Chairperson Camil Dumont, and his fellow COPE and Green Party of Vancouver Park Board Commissioners: turn the the staff governance report into a motion of Park Board at next Monday’s meeting, and risk that at some point down the road, your very own power as a duly elected Park Board Commissioner will be much diminished.
A risky venture for our elected Park Board Commissioners, anti-democratic in design and intention, and very much contrary to the public interest.

Metro Vancouver Alliance | Faithful Activism from the Heart, Pt. 2



As VanRamblings wrote yesterday, tonight at 5pm, the Metro Vancouver Alliance (MVA) — an alliance of faith, educational institutions, non-profits, and union groups located across the Metro Vancouver region — will hold a critically important fundraiser, titled Bridging the Gap, in order that the MVA might raise $15,000 in funds to hire a full-time organizer, matching funding for monies raised last month by member organizations within the MVA.

Bridging the Gap
Metro Vancouver Alliance Fundraiser
5pm, Wednesday, November 25, 2020
Register: click on
this link to RSVP

 

Today on VanRamblings, we’ll focus on two interviews we conducted yesterday with Deborah Littman, the Metro Vancouver Alliance’s original organizer, and Joey Hartman, the first chairperson of the MVA — both of whom will fill you in on the history of one of Metro Vancouver and our province’s most important, difference making social justice organizations.

Here’s Deborah Littman on the formation of the Metro Vancouver Alliance, issues the MVA addressed during her multi-year tenure, VanRamblings’ interview concluding with Ms. Littman’s insight into an April 2017 leadership debate at the Italian Cultural Centre, organized by the Metro Vancouver Alliance that, perhaps, helped to create the conditions for an “alliance” of two of the leaders on stage that night, subsequently allowing John Horgan and the B.C. New Democratic Party to form government in July 2017.

Metro Vancouver Alliance | Voices on the History of the MVA | Deborah Littman, Organizer, and former MVA Chair, Joey Hartman

Again, please attend tonight’s Metro Vancouver Alliance fundraiser.

Bridging the Gap
Metro Vancouver Alliance Fundraiser
5pm, Wednesday, November 25, 2020
Register: click on
this link to RSVP

 

Once you register for tonight’s fundraiser, the good folks at the Metro Vancouver Alliance will post a Zoom participant link to your e-mail address. The fundraiser will be online at 4:30pm this evening, with the official fundraiser to get underway at 5pm, the whole event to wrap at 5:45pm, as VanRamblings wrote yesterday, perhaps the best, most selfless and most rewarding activity in which you might engage throughout the entire upcoming holiday season.

The Metro Vancouver Alliance

The Metro Vancouver Alliance has established a charitable Canada Helps account. Whether you want to make a one time donation to the MVA, or become a sustaining monthly donor, all you have to do is click on this Canada Helps link, click the down arrow on the right-hand side of the page, choose the Metro Vancouver Alliance (MVA) option, and then click on the CONTINUE WITH DONATION “button”.


Give to the Metro Vancouver Alliance through Canada Helps. Click On This Graphic to Access the Canada Helps MVA website.

Click on the graphic above to go to the Canada Helps website, to donate to the Metro Vancouver Alliance’s Bridging the Gap Fundraiser. You’ll be glad you did! Don’t forget to click on the down arrow to choose the Metro Vancouver Alliance option.

Whether you give just once, or wish to become a sustaining MVA donor, your contribution to the Metro Vancouver Alliance will succeed in making a proportional difference of meaning in the lives of a great many people who need our help. As the MVA is designated as a non-profit, charitable organization, any donation you make will be tax deductible — all the more reason to give generously and from your heart. MVA members thank you.

The members of the Metro Vancouver Alliance look forward to meeting you online tonight.

See you then !!!

Metro Vancouver Alliance | Faithful Activism from the Heart, Pt. 1

The Metro Vancouver Alliance

For nearly 30 years now, the Metro Vancouver Alliance (MVA), an alliance of faith, non-profit, educational institutions and union groups situated across the Lower Mainland, has played a pivotal and continuing role in ensuring that those whom government and our society has let down and made vulnerable have a loud and clarion voice in helping set policy to redress the societal wrongs that inhibit their full participation in the life of the society.

In the 1990s, the group who would come to form the Metro Vancouver Alliance almost two decades later were comprised of various members of the faith and union communities across the metro Vancouver region, who came together, informally, to fight for change and social justice.

As you’ll hear tomorrow in an interview VanRamblings conducted with recent, and now retired, Metro Vancouver Alliance organizer, Deborah Littman, in point of fact, the genesis of what would become the Metro Vancouver Alliance did not begin to occur in earnest until 2009, with work continuing on through 2013, when as you’ll hear tomorrow from former Vancouver and District Labour Council President, and former Metro Vancouver Alliance chair, Joey Hartman, 1000 people of varied backgrounds and interests came together at the Maritime Labour Centre, to create what is now the thriving activist organization, the Metro Vancouver Alliance.

The Metro Vancouver Alliance group photo of MVA meeting

Although the Metro Vancouver Alliance has been around in some form or another dating back 1993, since 2013 in its most recent and current incarnation, the MVA has worked assiduously and with conscience to …

  • Develop innovative solutions to social isolation, to break down the pervasive sense of anomie that has so many in its grip, particularly in the time of our current COVID-19 pandemic;
  • Successfully worked with British Columbia’s current provincial government to establish free transit for children ages 5 through 12, in fact all children under the age of thirteen — an initiative enunciated by Premier John Horgan in the recent provincial election;
  • Successfully fought with the organizers within the Living Wage for Families offices to establish living wage policies in municipalities across not just the Metro Vancouver region, but across the entire province;
  • Committed to working with MVA member organizations and community groups to address the social and affordable housing crisis, to strengthen existing by-laws that protect the rights of tenants, and worked with municipal governments, and the province, to establish covenants that would mandate that landlords could not increase rents beyond the established provincial rate when tenants vacate an apartment, condominium, house or other housing type.

In recent days, Patrick Condon, the founding chair of the UBC urban design programme, and Vancouver City Councillor Colleen Hardwick have made contact with the Metro Vancouver Alliance to encourage the organization to work with them to establish a Tiny Homes pilot project, to be established at member locations of ten faith-based churches, synagogues and temples.

The Metro Vancouver Alliance | Bridging The Gap | Fundraiser

In order to continue the invaluable work of the Metro Vancouver Alliance, and in order that the MVA might hire a full-time organizer, the MVA is currently engaged in a fundraising campaign they’re calling Bridging the Gap, a fundraising initiative that it is hoped will raise $15,000 from a broad cross-section of community members of conscience who live across our region who are committed to social justice, monies that would match the $15,000 raised in 45 minutes at a Thursday, October 15th MVA meeting.

In the time of COVID-19, the Bridging the Gap Fundraiser will occur as a warmly engaging online participant Zoom meeting. You may consider today’s VanRamblings column your special invitation to participate in the Bridging the Gap Metro Vancouver Alliance Fundraiser, scheduled for 5pm tomorrow evening, on Wednesday, November 25th, 2020.

Bridging the Gap
Metro Vancouver Alliance Fundraiser
5pm, Wednesday, November 25, 2020
Register: click on
this link to RSVP

In order to participate in tomorrow night’s fundraiser, click on this link to RSVP for tomorrow evening’s fundraising meeting. Once registered, the good folks at the Metro Vancouver Alliance will post a Zoom participant link to your e-mail address. The fundraiser will be online from 4:30pm, with the official fundraiser getting underway at 5pm, the whole event to wrap at 5:45pm, perhaps the best, most selfless and most rewarding activity in which you might engage throughout the entire upcoming holiday season.

The Metro Vancouver Alliance has established a charitable Canada Helps account. Whether you want to make a one time donation to the MVA, or become a sustaining monthly donor, all you have to do is click on this Canada Helps link, click the down arrow on the right-hand side of the page, choose the Metro Vancouver Alliance (MVA) option, and then click on the CONTINUE WITH DONATION “button”.


Give to the Metro Vancouver Alliance through Canada Helps. Click On This Graphic to Access the Canada Helps MVA website.

Click on the graphic above to go to the Canada Helps website, to donate to the Metro Vancouver Alliance’s Bridging the Gap Fundraiser. You’ll be glad you did! Don’t forget to click on the down arrow to choose the Metro Vancouver Alliance option.

Whether you give just once, or wish to become a sustaining MVA donor, your contribution to the Metro Vancouver Alliance will succeed in making a proportional difference of meaning in the lives of a great many people who need our help. As the MVA is designated as a non-profit, charitable organization, any donation you make will be tax deductible — all the more reason to give generously and from your heart. MVA members thank you.

The members of the Metro Vancouver Alliance look forward to meeting you online at 5pm tomorrow evening. We’ll see you then !!!

Investigative Journalism | Why We All Must Subscribe to Media

subscribe.jpg

The future of journalism will increasingly depend on you paying for the news directly. Subscribing to newspapers, magazines and online journals represents nothing less than your essential duty to your fellow citizens, a necessary act of good citizenship, particularly when the algorithms developed by social media feeds like Facebook knowingly publish what can only be considered as “fake news”, and a true diminishment of knowledge.
The genesis of today’s VanRamblings derives from this tweet by longtime, respected Globe and Mail labour reporter, Rod Mickleburgh …


For those who don’t know: I love short form writing, have for almost 60 years now. As this is my blog, and in some sense an expression of what I care about, it is also (increasingly) about who I am, and how I have arrived at where I am in my life, psychologically, spiritually, philosophically and intellectually at the age of 70 years, and a few more COVID-19 months on.

Vancouver Public Library, at Burrard and Robson, circa 1963

As I’ve written previously, from age 6 on, I pretty much raised myself — my father worked the afternoon shift til 1 a.m. at the post office, and my mother worked evenings at Canada Packers / Swift Meats on Lulu Island. After making myself some dinner, or eating some stew that was bubbling away in the slow cooker, I was left to my own devices. Sometimes that involved going to the movies, sometimes in the 1960s that meant rehearsing for a play at Templeton Secondary school, but mostly it meant spending evenings at the Vancouver Public Library, at Robson and Burrard (pictured above). In some measure, librarians helped to raise me.
The library opened up previously unimaginable possibilities about what the future held, not only introducing me to the great works of literature, but providing me with insight into history, politics, development, and the arts.
Amidst the many tens of thousands of books, there was a newspaper and magazine room, where I would spend the better part of an hour each evening, reading through Time magazine, the London Times, the New York Times, the Manchester Guardian, the Toronto Star, and in time, the “gang of activists” folks who began publishing This Magazine, Canadian Forum and Canadian Dimension. I read newspapers from across the globe, and consumed magazines as if I was starved for information about the beauty and breadth of the world around me. I carried on that tradition of magazine and world newspaper reading while attending school at Simon Fraser University in the 1970s, and carry on that tradition thru until this very day.
At present, I subscribe to the following newspapers, magazines and …

News subscriptions

The Globe and Mail sets me back $29.36 each month, by far my most expensive subscription, I subscribe to the news channels through TELUS Optik TV. The annual subscription to the LA Times is $71.01 (or $5.92 a month), the Washington Post, $76.08 ($6.34 monthly), Slate Plus is $35.86 annually, while Vulture / New York magazine comes in at $27.36 for the year. The New York Times is $8.40 per month, and The Guardian is an even $5. The total monthly subscription to the news channels, and all the magazines above comes in at a whopping, easy-to-digest $67.28 a month.
Each morning when I arise to Stephen Quinn and The Early Edition, sometimes at 7 a.m., sometimes at 5 a.m., I immediately flip open the iPad Mini beside my bed, and click on the morning digest of news on my Flipboard app, a free and indispensable source of news.

Next, I surf through the New York and Los Angeles Times, then Slate, The Guardian, the Washington Post, and Vulture. Then, it’s up to make some breakfast while listening to the New York Times’ Michael Barbaro podcast, The Daily. Over breakfast I catch up on the news on CBC Network, the CTV News channel, CNN and MSNBC. After breakfast, it’s to my computer to continue with an hour of reading of the Globe, and the NY Times, the Washington Post and LA Times in depth, with a gander at Slate, and checking out Vulture / the New York magazine — and whatever I’ve found on Flipboard that I found interesting, in The Atlantic, Esquire, Vanity Fair, after which it’s off to Twitter and Facebook.
And then, after all that, I’m ready to begin my day.
Okay, okay, I can hear you say, “It’s alright for you to read and subscribe to so many news outlets, but not all of us have money to spend burning a hole in our pocket,” which will now lead to the following graph of my total income for 2019. I have an extra $75 in tax taken off, so I’ve got a bit of money, usually $900 in a tax return, each spring — thanks to my good friend (who knows how he puts up with me?) and accountant for nigh on 30 years, the spectacularly kind Patrick Mokrane, who’s kept me afloat financially thru his on the up-and-up derring do on my annual tax return.

Raymond Tomlin's 2019 tax return

A friend of mine tells me that he believes I live better on $1870.75 a month than anyone he knows. I have created an Excel spreadsheet that tracks every penny I spend, so that helps keeps me focused. My housing co-op monthly charge comes in at around $600, my bills (Internet, TV, mobility, home phone and Hydro, Netflix, Prime, etc.) comes in at around $245 — which leaves me with $67 for my subscriptions, $350 for food and household products, $75 a month on dining out or ordering in, another $75 a month for clothes and shoes — which, ordinarily, would leave me $400 each month left over to pay for dental, books, tech, insurance, hair cuts, donations to various causes (oh yes, I forgot, I donate $100 each month to the NDP provincially and federally, as well as to a faith organization, and various “causes”). Unfortunately, when in 2018 I came into a windfall arising from a 30-year-old union grievance I filed and won (for me, and hundreds of others locally), Canada Pension deducted that windfall from my annual income (economics - the dismal science), but in 2019 I had no such windfall, so in July Canada Pension cut my pension by $172.50 a month!
All of the above is by way of saying, if I can live relatively well on $1698 a month, or so, and can still prioritize subscriptions to various online news organizations, and donate monies to political parties I support, so can you.

digital-subscribe.jpg

As all of us are aware, it costs money to create content, and it costs a lot of money to fund good investigative journalism, as the nonprofit-run Mother Jones pointed out this year during a fundraising effort.
These past few years, we’ve also become aware of the controversy surrounding Mark Zuckerberg; the indifferent Facebook CEO claimed it was “crazy” that fake news on Facebook could have influenced the recent U.S. election results, or that his social media site has anything to do with aiding the repression of citizens across the globe. Sadly, that’s far from the truth.
Awhile back, Facebook eliminated the human editors who curated trending news; now an algorithm handles this — but the algorithm often gets it wrong, as stories from Russian bot sites present themselves as credible news organizations, make the rounds and trend on Facebook, feeding conspiracy theories and misinformation. Little wonder that, at last count, Facebook remains the world’s #1 purveyor of false or inaccurate news.
All of which is to say that you have an obligation to yourself, to those around you, and to society in general to keep yourself well-informed, and read credible news sites that are, in actuality, truly “fair and balanced.”
If you believe the newspapers and magazines above are a little too “conservative” for your liking, in Canada, there’s always rabble.ca, the public affairs journalism of richochet.ca, This Magazine, and Canadian Dimension, as well as down south, In These Times, Mother Jones, Crooks and Liars, and so many other left-of-centre journals and magazines that may be found online. There are places online where you can get credible, well-thought-out and researched, witty & engagingly written truthful news.

newspapers-magazines.jpg

Do yourself a favour today: subscribe to one or more online, or home delivery, newspaper, journal or magazine. You’ll feel better for it. Honest.