Category Archives: Vancouver Votes 2018

#VanPoli | Hope | City Council Finds Collegial Transcendence

Newly-elected Vancouver Mayor and City Councillors in chambers, November 2018Here they are: your new Mayor & City Councillors, in chambers and ready to get to work

Last Tuesday morning, November 13th, the first “business meeting” for Vancouver’s new Mayor and eight recently-elected, and two re-elected City Councillors, VanRamblings was seated in the balcony area above the round that is the seating of council chambers at Vancouver City Hall.
At 9:29am, standing for just a moment, peering over the guard rail down onto the now seated Mayor and Council, we glanced over to our left to see Christine Boyle turning to her seat mate, Rebecca Bligh, seated to her right, when a smile washed over Ms. Boyle’s face that simply lit up the room, the smile wordless, but saying so much: “Well, Rebecca, the next phase of our lives is about to begin. I don’t know what the future holds, but I do know this: we’re in this together, all of us in this room.”
Rebecca Bligh smiled back at Christine Boyle, centred and calming and utterly supportive of her new Council colleague, a zen presence in Council chambers, as serene as we’ve ever seen anyone around the Council “table”, utterly poised and composed, prepared for life to unfold before her.
VanRamblings then looked over at the new Mayor and each of the other Councillors who, although they may not have witnessed Christine Boyle’s beatific and reassuring smile, felt the impact of that smile, Colleen Hardwick also serene, as was the case with Pete Fry sitting next to her, Adriane Carr away for the first part of the meeting, fulfilling her responsibility as a Councillor to be present at the provincial government’s announcement of 4,950 new units of affordable housing across the province, a good number of which will begin construction in neighbourhoods across the City of Vancouver in the months to come.
Looking to our right, Sarah Kirby-Yung could also be seen smiling, utterly at peace around the Council table, as was the case with the seatmates to her right, Lisa Dominato, Michael Wiebe, Jean Swanson and Melissa De Genova.
The Vancouver Courier’s very fine civic affairs reporter, Mike Howell, yesterday published a column titled, Top 20 observations of new Vancouver council. We had already planned to do something similar today — but it would be unfair not to acknowledge that Mike got their first.
Last week, on Twitter, we published the following …

Civic affairs reporters try to keep their sanity reporting out on a new Vancouver City Council

Now, we got heck for posting the above Twitter comment, as if somehow we were being critical of our new, well-intentioned, wholesomely democratic Vancouver City Council — which observations by our critics couldn’t be further from the truth. Rather, our intention was to point out that during the course of a 12+ hour initial Council meeting, not a lot got done, the meeting bogged down (as pointed out by the observant Mr. Howell) in amendments, amendments to amendments, and a well-intentioned procedural hell that was not only frustrating for observers and Councillors, but for those reporters covering that first meeting.
All of us reporting out on, and observing, that first Council meeting realize that these are early days, and given the wit, the intelligence, the heart, the collegiality and the good will clearly evident around the Council table, sooner than later, the new Council will find their feet, accomplish that which needs doing, and build for themselves, and for all of us, a legacy of achievement that will stand in Vancouver civic history as an outstanding contribution to the livability of our city, towards building the city we need.
So, that’s the pre-amble to today’s column …
Random Observations on Vancouver City Council’s first week

  • Colleen Hardwick was mute throughout the entirety of the morning of the first Council meeting. In meetings such as this, Councillors most often feel compelled to weigh in on issues that come before Council — but, as we say, Ms. Hardwick remained mute the entire morning;

  • When Council broke for lunch, just outside of Council chambers, Colleen (we’ve been friends, so we’re going to refer her by her Christian name) greeted us warmly and in a friendly manner, for the first time in months. We were both bowled over, and grateful. Then Councillor Hardwick proceeded to initiate a scrum with reporters in the third floor foyer, where she blasted her Council mates. More on this in a moment;
  • On the second morning, Christine Boyle moved a motion that would ensure that all of Vancouver’s 23 neighbourhoods would be participant in a “building out” of affordable housing. Pete Fry, in support of Ms. Boyle’s motion, suggested an amendment that would include the words spatial justice, a term with which the distaff Councillor was obviously unfamiliar, as she rejected the suggested amendment by her colleague outright;
  • Later on that second day, Ms. Boyle suggested a supportive amendment to the wording of a motion placed before Council on 58 West Hastings. Christine Boyle’s suggested amendment was entirely supportive of the intent of Jean Swanson’s motion, but Ms. Swanson swatted away Ms. Boyle’s suggested amendment, as if it was the most irksome thing she’d heard at Council that day, or on any other day of her life;
  • Sarah Kirby-Yung, as may well be expected, emerged as the most articulate, well-reasoned Councillor, and contrary to her usual habit of speaking just a tad too quickly, around the Council table she spoke more slowly, injecting both a gravitas and authority that was quite something to witness (may we say, “Good on you, Sarah!” — note should be made that Ms. Kirby-Yung is pretty much the only Councillor that can stand to be around us, although the rest of the Councillors make a game effort to be kind to this old, if voluble, gentleman);
  • In the zen sweepstakes, Mayor Kennedy Stewart — who we have to say just knocked our socks off, friendly, reasonable, articulate, bright, and zen to a degree that is took more than a year for Gregor Robertson to develop (which he did, very much to his credit) in the Chair, and around the Council table the next couple of days — would seem to have competition from Rebecca Bligh. Now, as we’ve written previously, we were admiring of Ms. Bligh the first time we met her, as the most authentic and socially skilled person with whom we’d come into contact in years (there is greatness in this woman).

    Now, as anyone who knows us soon realizes, VanRamblings is bereft of even a hint of social skills (alas) — we tend to greatly admire those possessed of skills of which VanRamblings is completely incapable (another example: we will never be as articulate, well-spoken or as superb a writer as Pete Fry — it just is, and we’re grateful that his voice will be heard in Vancouver’s, and British Columbia’s, civic affairs) — the fact that Ms. Bligh also brings a zen approach to matters before Council, as well as a fine intellect, an ability to listen & peer into your soul, and a well-developed social conscience … just colour us mightily impressed!;

  • Back to Colleen Hardwick for a moment. VanRamblings officially calls for a truce between Ms. Hardwick and VanRamblings. Here’s what we figure about Colleen Hardwick on Council: Ms. Hardwick does not suffer fools gladly (those not agreeing with her fall into the category of ‘fools’). Ms. Hardwick was elected because she is outspoken — we believe that’s what those who supported her and voted for her expect, that she’ll speak her mind, and although she may be viewed as being impolitic from time to time, clearly Colleen believes there’s work to be done, and has every intention of lighting a fire under Council to get moving on her agenda, for which she expects Council’s co-operation. Council’s unanimous support for her call for development of a City Plan must be seen as a win for Councillor Hardwick — even if her motion calling for the revocation of duplexes as a housing type would seem destined for defeat (the motion was referred to staff — a general sign of death for a motion as originally drafted). Colleen Hardwick will be just fine on Council. As we say: truce;
  • For us, the most heartening development on Council is the well-deserved respect that Lisa Dominato is being afforded by her Council mates, something that we thought was unforgivably missing during her brief tenure on School Board. We continue to believe that Ms. Dominato is, and will be seen to be, a powerhouse on Council. We will live to our dying day regretting not endorsing her candidacy for Council — one cannot ask for forgiveness for the unforgivable, though, so we’ll simply be tremendously supportive of Councillor Dominato going forward, in all she does (reserving the right, of course, to be critical — as would be the case with her fellow Councillors — from time to time — but, respectfully);
  • We’ve already elucidated how we feel about Councillor Pete Fry — our enthusiasm for the work Pete will take on at Council is boundless, our good will for Councillor Fry unrelenting.

    And, oh yes, Councillor Fry missed a portion of the meeting last week: Pete was off doing work with the Union of B.C. Municipalities, to which body he is Council’s delegate. And, oh yes, part deux, Councillor Bligh missed a bit of Thursday’s Council tête-à-tête, as she was back east as Council’s delegate to the Federation of Canadian Municipalities;

  • We have to say, we feel pretty much the same thing about Councillor Michael Wiebe, who each hour and each day moves from strength to strength to strength. Michael’s potential to do good is … limitless;
  • Councillor Melissa De Genova — long one of our favourite electeds, for the record — moved the motion to refer Jean Swanson’s 58 West Hastings motion to staff, but while doing so and in her capacity as City Hall Budget Director stated her full and unwavering support for Councillor Swanson’s motion — although Ms. Swanson may not get the 130 units of income assistance level supportive housing she and others have so long fought for, we’re willing to bet that Council will achieve something pretty darn close to that, finally moving on a project that Vision Vancouver had kept in abeyance for seven years;

  • Adriane Carr: democrat.
    The voice of the people. Honestly, does anything more have to be said about Vancouver’s favourite City Councillor? Nope. Continue your good work, Councillor Carr.

And, finally, on the other good news front: Councillors Pete Fry and Christine Boyle’s motion to establish a Renter’s Office at City Hall (more on this another time) passed with flying colours, which is to say, unanimously — which is good for all of us, and most particularly, renters.
When most of the rest of the world seems to be falling apart, we here in Vancouver and in British Columbia, seem to be doing just fine — for which the voters and the citizens of our city and of our province, and the members of our new City Council and our new and glorious and humane NDP government, deserve our undying gratitude.
As Mike Howell writes … the next Council meeting, December 4th.

#VanPoli | East, West | North, South | Vancouver | A Divided City

Vancouver voting patterns show an east-west and a north-south divide

In an article published in the Vancouver Sun on Monday, reporter Dan Fumano quotes urban geographer Aaron Licker as saying …

“We’re adding people in these areas (Fairview & Mount Pleasant) that vote for parties that want more density,” said Licker, whose company Licker Geospatial Consulting does work for clients including civic governments and real estate companies. “The NPA can play to the single-family homeowners (on the west side of the city) forever, but they’re declining in terms of population. Forty years ago, most of Vancouver lived in single-family areas, but now most of Vancouver lives in multi-family zones.”

Licker’s thesis: the old east side / west side divide that dictated electoral outcomes in Vancouver is no longer as relevant as the north-south divide.
To that end, Licker publishes the following graphic …

Voting patterns in Vancouver, says urban geographer Aaron Licker, suggests a north-south divide

While VanRamblings doesn’t dispute Licker’s thesis outright, we’re not so sure that his hypothesis — despite the graphic you see above — that it is the north-south divide, rather than the traditional east-west divide that is the determining factor in which neighbourhoods vote for which parties, and which Mayoral candidates.
According to the data we publish below — taken directly from the vancouver.ca website (take a look at the drop down menus to see how your neighbourhood voted, not just for Mayor but, if you scroll down, for Council, Park and School Board) — we’re not so sure that the east side-west side divide is quite as irrelevant as Mr. Licker would have us believe.

Voters on the east side of Vancouver vote overwhelmingly for Kennedy Stewart as MayorYou’ll note, almost universally, voters on Vancouver’s east side voted overwhelmingly for the progressive, VDLC-endorsed candidate for Mayor, Kennedy Stewart.

For the most part, the west side continues to vote in their class and monied interests, while the east side votes in their working class voter interests.

Voters on Vancouver's west side voted overwhelmingly for the business candidate for Mayor, Ken SimYou’ll note, almost universally, voters on Vancouver’s west side voted overwhelmingly for the right-of-centre business candidate for Mayor, Ken Sim.

Single family dwelling west side voters tend to want to pay less property tax, while east side voters want government to provide neighbourhood amenities, inject a bit of humanity into the decision-making at city hall, and acknowledge the diverse cultural & ethnic make-up of our neighbourhoods.
Never the twain shall meet?
The new Vancouver City Council has a palpable opportunity to break down class and economic barriers, and govern for the whole city, be prudent fiscal managers, while providing services to the community. Vancouverites have never voted for as diverse a Vancouver City Council, with an independent Mayor who is dedicated to broaching the divide, and a Council with elected members from five different political — when has that ever happened in our city previous to the October 20th election?
A political divide has opened on our political landscape that must be bridged
The answer: never. All of which means, it’s time for change in Vancouver politics. No more of this left-right, east-west, north-south divide — we see what that’s done to our neighbours to the south. Is that what we want in Vancouver, in Canada? Perhaps I’m naïve, but I think the answer is no.

#VanPoli | City Council | The First Day of the Rest of Their Lives

Mayor and Vancouver City Councillors group photo in Council chambers on inauguration dayVancouver’s new City Council meeting for the first time, l-r: Councillors Rebecca Bligh, Christine Boyle, Colleen Hardwick, Pete Fry, Adriane Carr & Mayor Kennedy Stewart + Councillors Melissa De Genova, Jean Swanson, Michael Wiebe, Lisa Dominato and Sarah Kirby-Yung, where in City Council chambers 10 motions will be presented for a vote

Tuesday, November 13th, 2018 marks the first day that the newly-elected Mayor and 10 City Councillors get down to business, with a raft of motions due to hit the floor, either in late morning, or after the lunch break — it’s going to be a busy day at Council (which doesn’t sit well with retired City Councillor George Affleck, as may be seen in his cautionary tweet below).

Retired Vancouver City Councillor George Affleck suggests new Council slow down

Even so, there’s work to be done, campaign promises to be kept, even if such does occur amidst the 30-day intensive orientation process to which our new Mayor & Councillors continue to be subject through December 7th.

Sarah Kirby-Yung, Day 6 of her and Mayor Kennedy Stewart & her fellow Councillors 30-day orientationDid we mention that former Park Board Chairperson Sarah Kirby-Yung is our favourite newly-elected City Councillor — which takes some doing, cuz we just sorta love all of our new City Councillors (and Mayor), and what a great communicator we’ve long known Councillor Kirby-Yung to be, and of how much she is on your side, and how much she wants work to “work across the aisle”, for you, to bring good governance to City Hall, as she knows our Mayor and all of our new City Councillors intend and will strive for …

At Tuesday’s first official “business meeting” of the new City Council, there are controversial motions, and some not quite so controversial.
On the relatively non-controversial side of the ledger (at least, let’s hope the motion emerges as non-controversial) is Councillor Pete Fry’s motion on the creation of A Renter’s Office at the City of Vancouver, long overdue, an idea that all three of our new Mayor, Kennedy Stewart, Councillor Fry, and Councillor Christine Boyle (who has seconded Mr. Fry’s motion) talked about on the campaign trail, and intend to represent the interests of renters.

Vancouver City Councillor Colleen Hardwick introduces motion to dump duplexes Councillor Colleen Hardwick’s motion seeks to eliminate duplexes across a large area of Vancouver currently zoned for single family residences. Duplexes: eliminating this form of “gentle density” ameliorates Vancouver’s affordable housing crisis how? The Straight


On the more controversial side of the ledger, unsurprisingly given what we know of the mover of the motion, there’s Councillor Colleen Hardwick’s motion to dump the duplex, which strangely and perversely seems to have some support on both sides of the aisle at City Hall, the near unanimous “duplex motion” passed by the previous Council designed as one of many measures to create “gentle density” and increased affordability in single family neighbourhoods throughout the city (full disclosure: VanRamblings’ daughter, husband and two grandson’s live in & own a duplex in Kitsilano).
Before continuing, VanRamblings’ readers may want to look at Jennifer Bradshaw & Albert Huang article in The Straight, which reads in part …

“Duplexes were the first step city staff recommended under the last council toward increasing “missing middle” multifamily homes in the city, as part of an affordable housing plan. Before this, all multifamily homes, including duplexes, rowhouses, social and co-op homes, were banned on 75 percent of Vancouver land, and only the most expensive type of home, single-detached houses (historically known as “single-family houses”) were allowed.

The new councillor’s move to reinstate the ban on duplexes is the polar opposite of the direction Vancouver should be going for …”

At the very least, response to Councillor Hardwick’s motion oughta be interesting (which, as we all know, constitutes the old Chinese curse).

58 West Hastings, what it could and was designed to be, and what it is in 2018Social Housing. 58 West Hastings. What the site could be (left), what it is now (right).

Again, before continuing, it’s worth reading Nathan Crompton, Steffanie Ling and Caitlin Shane’s June 19, 2018 column, Battle for 58 West Hastings: Broken Promises and Co-optation in The Mainlander.
Here’s the bottom line: after years of activism by Jean Swanson, Wendy Pedersen, Ivan Drury, residents of the Downtown Eastside, and activists citywide, in 2011 Gregor Robertson and the members of his Vision Vancouver Council team “purchased” 58 West Hastings from developer Concord Pacific, swapping 58 West Hastings for another site at 117 East Hastings. Soon after the swap, on the steps of the Carnegie Centre, Mayor Robertson announced that it was his intention and the intention of Council to develop 130 units of social housing on the 58 West Hastings site.
Seven years on, regrettably and egregiously no such work has begun, as Vancouver’s homelessness housing (and opioid) crisis continues to burgeon.
To begin the process of addressing that appalling situation, at Council on Tuesday, newly-elected Vancouver City Councillor Jean Swanson will introduce a motion to “recommit (Council) to the community vision of 100% welfare / pension rate community controlled social housing and the former Mayor’s promise for the site at 58 West Hastings Street.”
Now, there are seven more motions that are due to come before Council on Tuesday, ranging from a motion by Councillor Swanson to protect woebegone renters from renovictions and aggressive buy-outs by developers, to a motion by Mayor Kennedy Stewart to strike an emergency opoioid task force, all of which motions (and more) may be found here.

Newly-elected Vancouver Mayor and City Councillors in chambers, November 2018Here they are: your new Mayor & City Councillors, in chambers and ready to get to work

Vancouver City Council meetings are live streamed here, and are available online afterwards. Tuesday’s Vancouver City Council meeting will begin at 9:30am, with all of our electeds chipper, in place and set to get to work.
This is your city, folks, and your new Vancouver City Council — who mean to do well for us. It’s worth taking a boo at the work in which our new Mayor and Council mean to engage, to break down your sense of isolation, anomie and cynicism, and to engender hope for our future.

#VanPoli | Generational Change at Vancouver City Hall

Mayor and Vancouver City Councillors group photo in Council chambers on inauguration dayVancouver’s new City Council, l-r: Councillors Rebecca Bligh, Christine Boyle, Colleen Hardwick, Pete Fry, Adriane Carr and Mayor Kennedy Stewart, and Councillors Melissa De Genova, Jean Swanson, Michael Wiebe, Lisa Dominato, and Sarah Kirby-Yung

In 2015, when Prime Minister Justin Pierre James Trudeau was sworn into office as Canada’s 23rd Prime Minister, as he and his family alighted from the bus that brought he and his family, and his new cabinet for the Swearing-In Ceremony at Rideau Hall on that sunny, chill November 4th 2015 afternoon, the first thing you noticed was not just the gender balance, but the relative youth of the cabinet he had selected to make decisions on behalf of Canadians. The average age of age of his cabinet is 50.7 years, the youngest cabinet in Canadian history, signaling generational change.
From 29-year-old Burlington MP Karina Gould, the youngest elected person ever to sit in cabinet, who was given responsibility for Electoral Reform after 31-year-old Peterborough — Kawartha MP Maryam Monsef, an Afghan refugee, was made Minister of the Status of Women, to 45-year-old François-Philippe Champagne, who represents the riding of Saint-Maurice — Champlain in the House of Commons of Canada, who was made Minister of Infrastructure and Communities, and 39-year-old Ahmed Hussen, a former National President of the Canadian Somali Congress, who was made Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship for the Government of Canada, generational change was brought to the Cabinet decision-making.
Note. 35-year-old Bardish Chagger, MP for Waterloo, Ontario, assumed the responsibilities of Leader of the Government in the House of Commons on August 19, 2016, in addition to the responsibilities she already held as Minister of Small Business, while 36-year-old Canadian MP for Ahuntsic-Cartierville, Mélanie Joly became Minister of Canadian Heritage, and now the Minister of Tourism, Official Languages & La Francophonie.
A young cabinet lead by a 43-year-old Prime Minister with a young family represented what VanRamblings had written about during the six-month lead-up to the 2015 Canadian general election: generational change.
With the midterm election in the United States just complete, not only have we witnessed more women elected to government in the United States than ever before (110 women in Congress, double the number of only two years ago), what we also witnessed was (you guessed it): generational change, the average age of Congress almost a decade younger than the last Congress, from 29-year-old Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (the youngest member ever elected to Congress) to Abby Finkenhauer — who is just a few months older — who flipped an Iowa seat from red to blue, and who ran on a platform of worker and reproductive justice; Max Rose, a Purple Heart veteran, registered nurse Lauren Underwood, water rights attorney Xochitl Torres Small, openly bisexual newcomer Katie Hill, and Colorado’s first black Congressman Joe Neguse — all of whom are under 35 — lowering the average age of a Congressperson from 58 years to 49 years.

Mayor and Vancouver City Councillors group photo in Council chambers on inauguration dayVancouver’s new City Council, l-r: Councillors Rebecca Bligh, Christine Boyle, Colleen Hardwick, Pete Fry, Adriane Carr and Mayor Kennedy Stewart, and Councillors Melissa De Genova, Jean Swanson, Michael Wiebe, Lisa Dominato, and Sarah Kirby-Yung

Look at the photo directly above & what do you see? Generational change.
Councillors Rebecca Bligh, Christine Boyle, Pete Fry, Melissa De Genova, Michael Wiebe, Lisa Dominato and Sarah Kirby-Yung — seventeen to thirty-nine years younger than outgoing City Councillors Raymond Louie, George Affleck, Elizabeth Ball, Tim Stevenson, Kerry Jang (and Geoff Meggs & Tony Tang, before them): all, together, representing generational change.
No more will Vancouver Non-Partisan Association City Councillor Melissa De Genova, and City Council’s new Budget & Finance Director, be made to feel that, as she expounded on the campaign trail, and as she has written many, many times that, in the last term on Council, she was designated to the role of “a child sitting at the kid’s table”, her intelligence and her passion for social justice ignored by her “older” Council colleagues.
VanRamblings continues to be heartened at the election of persons of conscience to Vancouver City Hall, and the wisdom of voters in selecting what we continue to believe will emerge as the most progressive Vancouver City Council in more than 46 years. Whether by dint of youthful vigour and the ideals and passion of a millennial generation of decision-makers at Council, or the youthful and progressive ideas of Mayor Kennedy Stewart, and Councillors Colleen Hardwick, Adriane Carr, and Jean Swanson, hope lies on the near horizon toward realizing a fairer and more just city for all, and very much the city we need, representing every citizen of Vancouver.